How to Hire a Property Manager: Questions, Costs, Red Flags

Hiring a property manager can be one of the best decisions you make as a real estate investor—or one of the worst. The right property manager maximizes your rental income, keeps tenants happy, and lets you sleep at night. The wrong one bleeds your profits, creates legal headaches, and damages your investment.

This comprehensive guide walks you through every step of hiring a property manager, from knowing when you need one to spotting red flags that signal you should walk away.

When You Need a Property Manager

Not every landlord needs professional [property management](/blog/property-management-complete-guide). Consider hiring a property manager if:

You live far from your rental property. Managing tenants, maintenance, and emergencies becomes exponentially harder when you're not local. If you're more than an hour away from your rental, professional management usually makes sense.

You own multiple properties. Once you pass 3-5 units, property management becomes a full-time job. Your time is better spent finding new deals than fixing toilets and chasing late rent.

You hate being a landlord. Some investors love the hands-on work. Others despise it. If tenant calls ruin your day and maintenance requests stress you out, outsource it. Your mental health is worth the management fee.

You have a demanding career. If you're a surgeon, executive, or entrepreneur, your hourly rate probably far exceeds what you'd save by self-managing. Focus on what you do best and delegate property management.

You lack local knowledge. Investing in out-of-state markets requires local expertise you don't have. A good property manager knows the rental market, [contractor](/blog/diy-vs-contractor) rates, and local landlord-tenant laws.

What Property Managers Actually Do

Property managers handle the day-to-day operations of your rental property. Here's what you should expect:

Tenant screening and placement: Advertising vacancies, showing the property, running background and credit checks, verifying income and employment, and selecting qualified tenants.

Rent collection: Collecting monthly rent, enforcing late fees, sending notices, and handling payment processing. Good managers make rent collection systematic, not emotional.

Maintenance and repairs: Coordinating routine maintenance, responding to tenant repair requests, managing contractors, and handling emergencies 24/7. They should have trusted vendor relationships that get you better pricing.

Legal compliance: Understanding local, state, and federal landlord-tenant laws, handling proper notice requirements, managing the [eviction process](/blog/how-to-handle-eviction) when necessary, and keeping you compliant.

Financial reporting: Providing monthly statements showing income and expenses, tracking maintenance costs, and delivering year-end reports for tax purposes.

Property inspections: Conducting regular property inspections (typically quarterly or semi-annually), documenting property condition, and identifying maintenance issues before they become expensive problems.

Move-ins and move-outs: Managing the entire move-in process including lease signing and security deposits, conducting move-out inspections, coordinating cleaning and repairs, and handling security deposit returns per state law.

How Much Property Managers Cost

[Property management fees](/blog/property-management-fees-guide) vary by market and property type, but here are typical ranges:

Monthly management fee: Usually 8-12% of monthly rent for long-term residential properties. In competitive markets or for premium properties, you might negotiate down to 6-7%. For short-term rentals, expect 20-30%.

Leasing fee: Also called a placement fee or tenant placement fee. Typically 50-100% of one month's rent for finding and placing a new tenant. Some managers include this in monthly fees; others charge it separately.

Maintenance markup: Many property managers mark up contractor work by 10-20%. Some are transparent about this; others bury it in invoices. Always ask upfront.

Eviction fees: Additional fees for managing the eviction process, typically $200-$500 on top of legal and court costs.

Inspection fees: Some charge $75-$150 for move-in, move-out, or periodic inspections. Others include this in monthly management.

Other potential fees: Lease renewal fees ($100-$300), early termination fees if you fire them, property photography for listings, online listing fees, and coordination fees.

Do the math. On a $2,000/month rental with 10% management, you're paying $2,400/year plus a leasing fee every time you turn a tenant (potentially another $2,000). That's $4,400 in a turnover year. Make sure the value justifies the cost.

Essential Questions to Ask Property Managers

Come to your interviews prepared. Here are the critical questions:

How many properties do you currently manage? You want someone with substantial experience but not so overextended they can't give you attention. One property manager should handle no more than 100-150 units.

How many properties do you manage in this neighborhood? Local knowledge matters enormously. A manager with 20 properties in your neighborhood knows the market, the tenant pool, and the best contractors.

What's your average vacancy rate? Good managers keep properties rented. The market average in your area is your baseline. Anything significantly higher is a red flag.

How do you screen tenants? They should run comprehensive background checks, credit reports, verify income (usually 3x rent), check rental history, and contact previous landlords. Lazy screening leads to problem tenants.

What's your eviction rate? Some evictions are unavoidable, but a high eviction rate (over 10-15% annually) suggests poor tenant screening or management.

How quickly do you respond to maintenance requests? Emergencies should get same-day response. Routine maintenance within 24-48 hours. Slow responses lead to angry tenants and property damage.

Do you have in-house maintenance, or do you use contractors? Either can work, but you need to understand their system and markup structure.

How do you handle after-hours emergencies? You need 24/7 coverage. Some use answering services; others rotate on-call staff. No coverage means you're getting 2 AM calls.

What software do you use? Modern property managers use [property management software](/blog/best-property-management-software-2026) (Buildium, AppFolio, Propertyware) that gives owners online portals to view finances, maintenance requests, and documents in real-time.

Can I see a sample financial report? You need clear, detailed monthly statements. Vague or incomplete reporting makes it impossible to track your investment performance.

How do you determine rental rates? They should provide market analysis using recent comparable rentals, not gut feelings or outdated data.

What's your lease renewal strategy? Good managers start renewal conversations 60-90 days before lease expiration, reducing costly turnovers.

Who pays for tenant placement ads? Some managers include marketing in their fees; others pass costs through to owners.

What's your process if I want to sell the property? Understand notice requirements and any fees for early termination.

Red Flags to Watch For

These warning signs should make you walk away:

No license or certification. Many states require property management licenses. Even where not required, certifications like CPM (Certified Property Manager) or NARPM membership demonstrate professionalism.

Vague fee structure. If they can't clearly explain all fees upfront, expect surprise charges later.

Poor communication. If they're slow to respond during the courtship phase, it gets worse after you sign.

No written management agreement. Everything should be in writing. Handshake deals lead to disputes.

They don't maintain trust accounts. Security deposits and rent must be kept in separate trust accounts, not mixed with business operating funds. This is required by law in most states.

No errors and omissions insurance. Property managers should carry E&O insurance to protect you from their mistakes.

Bad online reviews. Check Google, Yelp, and BBB. A few bad reviews are normal, but patterns of complaints about communication, finances, or maintenance are serious red flags.

They don't inspect properties regularly. Properties deteriorate when no one's watching. Quarterly inspections minimum.

Pressure tactics. Good property managers don't need to pressure you. Desperation suggests they're struggling to keep clients.

They manage properties they own as direct competitors. Conflicts of interest arise when your property competes with theirs for tenants.

No local office. Out-of-area managers can work, but local presence usually means better service and faster response times.

The Interview Process

Interview at least three property managers before deciding. Here's how to evaluate them:

Request references. Talk to current clients, not just the handpicked testimonials. Ask about communication, financial accuracy, and problem-solving.

Drive by properties they manage. Are they well-maintained? Are lawns mowed? Does the neighborhood match your property?

Review the management agreement carefully. Look for one-sided terms, automatic renewal clauses, and hidden fees. Everything should be negotiable.

Check their financial stability. A property manager going out of business mid-contract creates enormous headaches.

Evaluate their responsiveness. How quickly do they return your calls and emails? This is how they'll treat tenants and maintenance issues.

Ask about their team. Who handles maintenance calls? Who manages accounting? Who screens tenants? You need to know the actual people doing the work.

Understand termination terms. Can you fire them with 30 days notice, or are you locked in? What happens to tenant deposits? Who keeps lease agreements?

Making the Final Decision

Price matters, but it shouldn't be the deciding factor. A manager charging 8% who keeps your property rented at top dollar with great tenants beats a 6% manager with constant vacancies and problem tenants.

Look for:

• Strong local presence and knowledge
• Clear, detailed communication
• Modern systems and technology
• Transparent pricing with no hidden fees
• Relevant experience with your property type
• Excellent references from current clients
• Proper licensing and insurance

The best property managers become true partners in your [real estate investing](/blog/brrrr-strategy-guide) journey. They protect your investment, maximize your returns, and free you to focus on growing your portfolio.

Take your time with this decision. A good property manager can manage your properties for years or even decades. The wrong one can cost you tens of thousands in lost rent, property damage, and legal fees.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to hire a property manager?

Plan for 2-4 weeks from starting your search to signing a management agreement. This includes researching candidates, conducting interviews, checking references, and reviewing contracts. Don't rush—this is a critical decision that affects your investment for years.

Can I negotiate property management fees?

Yes, especially if you own multiple properties or higher-value rentals. Managers are often flexible on monthly management percentages, though leasing fees are harder to negotiate. Your best leverage is committing multiple properties or offering a longer initial term.

Should I use a large company or a smaller boutique property manager?

Both have advantages. Large companies offer systems, backup staff, and financial stability. Smaller firms often provide more personal service and flexibility. Match the manager to your needs—large portfolios often benefit from corporate systems, while single-property owners might prefer boutique service.

What happens to my tenants when I hire a property manager?

Existing tenants typically transition to the new manager. The property manager will introduce themselves, provide new contact information for maintenance and rent payment, and continue the existing lease terms. Some states require tenant notification 30 days before transferring management.

Can I fire my property manager if they're not performing?

Most management agreements allow termination with 30-60 days written notice. Review your contract carefully for termination clauses, final accounting procedures, and return of tenant deposits and documents. Document performance issues before terminating.

Do property managers handle evictions?

Most do, though some charge additional fees beyond their monthly management percentage. They should manage the entire process including legal notices, court filings, and coordinating with attorneys. However, you as the owner are ultimately responsible for eviction costs and lost rent.

How involved will I be as the owner?

This varies by agreement, but most property managers handle day-to-day operations independently, consulting you only for major decisions like capital expenditures over a certain threshold (often $500-$1,000), lease renewals at below-market rates, or accepting tenants with credit issues. You'll receive monthly financial reports and can check in anytime.

What if my property manager isn't maintaining my property?

This is a serious issue. Start by documenting specific problems with photos and dates. Schedule a meeting to address concerns directly. If problems continue, conduct an independent property inspection and review your management agreement's termination clause. Persistent neglect justifies immediate termination.

Are property management fees tax deductible?

Yes, property management fees are fully tax-deductible as [operating expenses](/blog/net-operating-income-guide) for rental properties. Keep all invoices and statements for tax filing. Management fees reduce your taxable rental income, lowering your overall tax liability.

Should I use the same property manager for all my rentals?

It depends. Multiple properties with one manager often means better pricing and more attention. However, if you invest in different markets, you might need different local managers. Some investors use one manager per market, building strong relationships in each area where they own properties.

Related Articles

• Best College Towns for Rental Property Investment
• How to Identify the Best Neighborhoods for Rental Property Investment (Data-Driven Approach)
• [[Best States for Rental Property](/blog/best-states-for-rental-property-investment-2026) Investment in 2026 - Cash Flow & Appreciation](/blog/best-states-for-rental-property-investment-2026)