Property Management: The Complete Guide to DIY vs. Hiring a Property Manager

Owning rental property is one of the most reliable ways to build wealth in the United States. But the moment you close on that [first investment property](/blog/buying-multi-family-first-property), a critical question lands in your lap: do you manage it yourself, or do you hand it off to a professional property manager?

The answer isn't obvious. DIY management can save you thousands of dollars per year, but it can also cost you thousands in mistakes, vacancies, and legal exposure. Hiring a property manager gives you freedom, but eats into your cash flow.

This guide breaks down both options with real numbers, so you can make an informed decision based on your situation—not someone else's sales pitch.

What Does Property Management Actually Involve?

Before you can decide who should do the work, you need to understand what the work is. Property management covers:

• Tenant acquisition: Marketing the property, showing it, screening applicants, signing leases
• Rent collection: Collecting payments, enforcing late fees, handling partial payments
• Maintenance coordination: Responding to repair requests, scheduling contractors, handling emergencies
• Financial management: Tracking income and expenses, paying bills, providing owner statements
• Legal compliance: Following fair housing laws, handling security deposits correctly, managing evictions
• Lease enforcement: Addressing violations, conducting inspections, managing renewals

That's a lot of hats. Some landlords wear them all comfortably. Others find out the hard way that they hate getting 2 AM phone calls about burst pipes.

The Real Cost of Hiring a Property Manager

Property management companies typically charge between 8% and 12% of monthly collected rent. On a property renting for $2,000 per month, that's $160 to $240 per month, or $1,920 to $2,880 per year.

But the monthly percentage is only part of the picture. Most property managers also charge:

For a $2,000/month rental with one tenant turnover per year, the total annual cost of professional management can easily reach $5,000 to $7,000. On a property that generates $24,000 in gross annual rent, that's 21% to 29% of your top line.

When Professional Management Makes Financial Sense

Despite the cost, hiring a property manager makes sense in several scenarios:

1. You own multiple properties. Managing one property takes roughly 5–10 hours per month. Managing five takes 25–50 hours. At some point, your time is worth more than the management fee.

2. You live far from the property. If your rental is more than an hour's drive away, handling showings, inspections, and emergencies becomes impractical. Long-distance landlording without a property manager leads to deferred maintenance and higher turnover.

3. You have a high-paying job. If you earn $100 per hour at your day job and property management takes 10 hours per month, you're effectively paying $1,000 per month in opportunity cost to save $200 in management fees.

4. You don't want to learn landlord-tenant law. Property management mistakes have legal consequences. If you're not willing to learn the rules, pay someone who already knows them.

5. You're scaling your portfolio. Professional management creates systems that let you acquire more properties without proportionally increasing your workload.

The DIY Property Management Path

Self-managing means you handle everything—or at least everything you don't delegate to individual contractors. Here's what it takes.

Time Commitment

For a single-family rental with a stable tenant, expect to spend 3–5 hours per month on average. That includes responding to maintenance requests, reviewing financials, and occasional communication with your tenant.

During turnover, the time spikes dramatically. Marketing, showing, screening, cleaning, repairing, and leasing can consume 20–40 hours over a 2–4 week period.

Skills You Need

Communication. You'll deal with tenants, contractors, and sometimes attorneys. Clear, professional, documented communication prevents most landlord headaches.

Basic accounting. You need to track every dollar in and out. Software like Stessa, Avail, or even a well-organized spreadsheet works. The IRS expects detailed records at tax time.

Legal knowledge. You must understand your state and local landlord-tenant laws. This includes security deposit rules, notice requirements, habitability standards, and fair housing regulations. Ignorance is not a defense.

Maintenance triage. You don't need to be a plumber, but you need to know the difference between a $50 fix and a $5,000 emergency so you can respond appropriately.

Tools for DIY Landlords

The technology available to self-managing landlords has improved dramatically:

• [Tenant screening](/blog/best-property-management-software-2026): TransUnion SmartMove, RentPrep, or Avail offer credit checks, background checks, and eviction history for $30–$55 per applicant
• Rent collection: Zelle, Avail, TurboTenant, or Baselane offer free or low-cost online rent collection
• Lease creation: State-specific lease templates from EZLandlordForms, LawDepot, or your local landlord association ($30–$100)
• Maintenance tracking: TurboTenant, Avail, or a simple shared document where tenants submit requests
• Accounting: Stessa (free for basic), Baselane, or QuickBooks

With these tools, a single-property landlord can run a professional operation for under $200 per year in software costs.

Common DIY Mistakes to Avoid

Skipping tenant screening. The single most expensive mistake a landlord can make is placing a bad tenant. A thorough screening process—credit check, background check, income verification, rental history, and references—costs $30–$55 and can save you $5,000 to $30,000 in eviction costs, lost rent, and property damage.

Ignoring fair housing laws. The Fair Housing Act protects seven classes: race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and disability. Many states and cities add additional protections. One careless comment during a showing can result in a discrimination complaint with damages ranging from $10,000 to $100,000+.

Not documenting everything. Every conversation, every repair, every complaint should be documented in writing. If it's not in writing, it didn't happen—at least in court.

Deferring maintenance. A $200 plumbing repair today prevents a $5,000 water damage claim tomorrow. Preventive maintenance is cheaper than emergency repairs, and tenants who live in well-maintained properties stay longer.

Using a handshake instead of a lease. A month-to-month verbal agreement might feel simpler, but it leaves both parties unprotected. Use a written lease, every time, for every tenant.

Hybrid Approaches

You don't have to choose 100% DIY or 100% professional management. Many landlords use hybrid models:

Self-manage with a leasing agent. Handle day-to-day operations yourself, but hire a real estate agent or leasing specialist to handle tenant placement. Leasing agents typically charge 50%–100% of one month's rent, but they handle marketing, showings, screening, and lease signing.

Self-manage with a maintenance coordinator. Some handyman services and property maintenance companies offer subscription plans ($100–$200/month) that handle all maintenance coordination while you handle everything else.

Property manager for some properties, DIY for others. If you have a mix of local and distant properties, manage the nearby ones yourself and hire a manager for the distant ones.

How to Choose a Property Manager

If you decide to hire, don't just pick the cheapest option. A bad property manager can be worse than no property manager.

Questions to Ask

1. How many units do you currently manage?
2. What is your average vacancy rate and time to fill?
3. How do you handle maintenance requests and what's your average response time?
4. Do you mark up contractor invoices?
5. What does your monthly owner statement look like? Can I see a sample?
6. How do you screen tenants? What are your minimum criteria?
7. What happens if I want to terminate the management agreement?
8. Are you licensed in this state? (Required in most states.)
9. How often do you conduct property inspections?
10. What is your eviction rate and process?

Red Flags

• They won't share their management agreement before you sign
• They guarantee specific rental rates without seeing the property
• They don't conduct regular inspections
• They have poor online reviews, especially about communication
• They manage too many units per staff member (industry standard is 50–100 units per manager)

Making the Decision: A Framework

Ask yourself these five questions:

1. How much is my time worth? If the management fee is less than what you'd earn spending that time elsewhere, hire a manager.
2. How far am I from the property? More than 60 minutes? Strongly consider hiring.
3. Am I willing to learn landlord-tenant law? If not, hire a manager.
4. How many properties do I own or plan to own? 1–3 nearby properties are manageable. Beyond that, the math starts favoring professional management.
5. Can I handle difficult conversations? Collecting late rent, enforcing lease terms, and managing evictions require emotional discipline. If confrontation makes you freeze, a property manager is worth every penny.

FAQs

How much does a property manager cost for a single-family home?

Expect to pay 8%–12% of monthly rent for ongoing management, plus a leasing fee of 50%–100% of one month's rent each time a new tenant is placed. For a home renting at $2,000/month, total annual costs typically range from $4,000 to $7,000 depending on turnover.

Can I switch from DIY to a property manager (or vice versa) at any time?

You can hire a property manager at any time, though existing leases transfer with the property. Going from managed to self-managed requires giving notice per your management agreement—usually 30–90 days—and you may owe an early termination fee.

Is property management income tax-deductible?

Yes. [Property management fees](/blog/property-management-fees-guide) are a deductible expense on Schedule E of your tax return. So are most other costs of managing rental property, including software, mileage, repairs, and legal fees.

Do I need a license to manage my own rental property?

In most states, you do not need a license to manage your own property. However, if you manage properties for other people for compensation, most states require a real estate broker's license or a specific property management license.

What's the biggest risk of self-managing?

Legal exposure. Fair housing violations, improper evictions, security deposit mishandling, and habitability issues can all result in lawsuits with damages far exceeding the cost of professional management. Education and [documentation](/blog/heloc-documentation-requirements) are your best defenses.

How do I know if my property manager is doing a good job?

Track vacancy rates, [tenant retention](/blog/tenant-turnover-cost-guide), maintenance costs, and communication responsiveness. A good property manager fills vacancies within 2–4 weeks, retains tenants for 2+ years on average, and responds to your inquiries within one business day.

The Bottom Line

There's no universally right answer. DIY management works great for hands-on investors with 1–3 nearby properties and the willingness to learn. Professional management makes sense for busy professionals, long-distance investors, and anyone scaling beyond a few units.

The worst choice is the one you make by default. Be intentional. Run the numbers. And whatever you decide, treat your rental property like the business it is.

Related Articles

• [Best College Towns for [Rental Property Investment](/blog/best-states-for-rental-property-investment-2026)](/blog/best-college-towns-for-rental)
• [Best Investment Property Lenders in 2026 - Rental & [Multifamily Loans](/blog/best-investment-property-lenders-2026)](/blog/best-investment-property-lenders-2026)
• How to Identify the Best Neighborhoods for Rental Property Investment (Data-Driven Approach)