ESA and Service Animals: Landlord's Legal Guide

Assistance animals—including service animals and emotional support animals—are one of the most misunderstood areas of landlord-tenant law. Many landlords mistakenly believe they can apply pet policies to these animals, while others fear they must accept any animal a tenant claims is an ESA, even from questionable online registries.

The truth lies between these extremes. Federal Fair Housing laws require landlords to make reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities who need assistance animals, but landlords also have rights to verify requests and deny animals that pose genuine threats or lack proper [documentation](/blog/heloc-documentation-requirements).

This guide explains everything landlords need to know about service animals and emotional support animals, including the legal framework, verification procedures, when you can say no, and how to handle requests properly.

Legal Framework: Two Different Laws

Two federal laws govern assistance animals, and understanding the difference is crucial:

Fair Housing Act (FHA)

• Applies to housing (rental properties, condos, HOAs)
• Covers both service animals and emotional support animals
• Requires reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities
• Landlords can verify disability and need (for ESAs)
• Cannot charge pet deposits or pet rent for assistance animals

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)

• Applies to public accommodations (stores, restaurants, hotels, government buildings)
• Covers service animals only (not emotional support animals)
• Service animals must be specifically trained to perform tasks
• Very limited verification allowed
• ESAs have NO rights under ADA in public spaces

Critical Distinction: An emotional support animal has housing rights under FHA but cannot go into restaurants, stores, or other public places. A service animal has rights under both FHA and ADA.

Service Animals: Defined

What Qualifies as a Service Animal

Under the ADA and FHA, a service animal is:

• A dog (or in rare cases, a miniature horse)
• Individually trained to perform specific tasks or work
• For a person with a disability
• Tasks must be directly related to the person's disability

Examples of Service Animal Tasks

Valid Service Tasks:

• Guiding people who are blind or have low vision
• Alerting people who are deaf or hard of hearing
• Pulling wheelchairs or providing mobility assistance
• Alerting and protecting someone having a seizure
• Reminding someone to take medication
• Calming someone with PTSD during an anxiety attack (active task, not just presence)
• Detecting allergens in food
• Retrieving items for someone with mobility limitations

NOT Service Animal Tasks:

• Simple companionship or emotional support
• Crime deterrence through presence alone
• Protection/guard dog functions unrelated to disability

What You Can Ask About Service Animals

You MAY ask:

1. "Is this animal required because of a disability?"
2. "What work or task has this animal been trained to perform?"

You CANNOT ask:

• About the nature or severity of the disability
• For medical documentation
• For demonstration of the task
• For certification or registration
• To see ID cards or vests

You CANNOT require:

• Special certification or training documentation
• Specific trainer credentials
• Registration in any database
• Vest, ID card, or other identification

Why verification is limited: Service animals are medical equipment, like wheelchairs. You wouldn't ask someone to prove why they need a wheelchair.

Service Animals Are NOT Pets

Service animals:

• Cannot be charged pet deposits or pet rent
• Cannot be restricted by "no pets" policies
• Cannot be restricted by breed, size, or weight limits (with narrow exceptions)
• Must be allowed in all areas tenants can access
• Are not subject to pet-related lease clauses

Emotional Support Animals (ESAs): Defined

What Qualifies as an ESA

An emotional support animal:

• Provides therapeutic benefit through companionship
• Alleviates symptoms of a disability
• Does NOT require specific training
• Can be any species (dogs, cats, birds, rabbits, etc.)
• Is prescribed/recommended by healthcare professional

Key Differences from Service Animals

What You Can Require for ESA Verification

Unlike service animals, you CAN require documentation for ESAs:

Acceptable Documentation:

1. Letter from licensed healthcare provider (therapist, psychologist, psychiatrist, physician, social worker)
2. Provider must have treating relationship with tenant
3. Letter must state:
   • Tenant has a disability (no need to specify which)
   • The animal provides disability-related assistance/therapeutic benefit
   • Tenant needs the specific animal (or type of animal)

Inadequate Documentation:

• Online "ESA registration" certificates (not valid legal documentation)
• ESA letters from online services with no treating relationship
• Generic letters not specific to the tenant
• Letters from friends, family, or non-licensed individuals
• Internet purchases of vests, ID cards, or certificates

Red Flags for Fraudulent ESA Requests

Be suspicious of:

• Online ESA certificates purchased without healthcare consultation
• Brand new "therapist" relationship right before housing application
• Letter from provider who's never met tenant in person or via telehealth
• Generic form letters clearly mass-produced
• Provider who specializes in ESA letters (ESA mills)
• No specific information about tenant's need
• Letters that cite non-existent laws or "registration requirements"

What to do: You can request additional information or clarification if the documentation is insufficient. You can verify the healthcare provider is licensed.

The Interactive Process: How to Handle Requests

When a tenant requests an assistance animal accommodation:

Step 1: Receive the Request

• Request can be oral or written (though written is better for documentation)
• Can occur before lease signing or during tenancy
• Must be taken seriously regardless of format

Step 2: Determine If Verification Is Needed

For Service Animals:

• If disability and need are obvious, no documentation needed
• Can only ask the two permitted questions
• Cannot require documentation

For ESAs:

• Can require documentation from healthcare provider
• Can verify disability exists (but not details)
• Can verify disability-related need for the specific animal

Step 3: Request Documentation (ESAs only)

Provide written request for:

• Letter from licensed healthcare provider
• Confirmation of disability (not the specific diagnosis)
• Explanation of disability-related need for animal

Sample Request Letter: "We received your request for a reasonable accommodation to have an emotional support animal. To evaluate your request, please provide a letter from a licensed healthcare provider who has treated you, stating that you have a disability and explaining how the animal provides disability-related assistance. Please submit this documentation within 14 days."

Step 4: Review Documentation

Verify:

• Provider is licensed in your state
• Letter is specific to this tenant (not generic)
• Letter addresses disability and need
• Provider has legitimate treating relationship

You can:

• Contact provider to verify they wrote the letter
• Ask clarifying questions if letter is vague
• Request updated documentation if letter is outdated

You cannot:

• Ask about specific diagnosis or treatment
• Require specific forms or formats
• Demand details about the disability
• Require provider to explain why this animal rather than medication

Step 5: Approve or Deny

Must approve if:

• Tenant has verified disability
• Animal provides disability-related assistance
• Accommodation is reasonable
• Doesn't create undue burden or direct threat

Can deny if:

• No verifiable disability or need
• Animal poses direct threat to health/safety of others
• Animal would cause substantial physical damage that cannot be reduced/eliminated
• Accommodation would create undue financial/administrative burden
• Fundamentally alters the nature of the housing provider's operations

Step 6: Document Decision

Provide written response:

• Approval: Confirm accommodation granted, outline any conditions
• Denial: Explain specific reason, offer to engage in interactive process for alternative accommodation

Timeline: Respond within reasonable time (10-14 days is typical).

When You Can Deny an Assistance Animal Request

Valid Reasons to Deny

1. Lack of Disability or Disability-Related Need

• No documentation provided (for ESA)
• Documentation from non-licensed provider
• No treating relationship between provider and tenant
• Letter doesn't establish disability-related need

Example: "Please provide a letter from a licensed healthcare provider you have an established relationship with, as the online certificate you provided is not adequate documentation under Fair Housing law."

2. Direct Threat to Health or Safety

• Animal has documented history of dangerous behavior
• Specific instance of aggression or injury
• Must be based on objective evidence, not assumptions about breed or species

Cannot deny based on:

• Breed alone (pit bulls, German shepherds, etc.)
• Size alone
• Fear or assumptions without evidence
• Other tenants' complaints without actual threatening behavior

Example of valid denial: "We are denying your request for this specific animal because it has a documented history of biting, as evidenced by the incident report from your previous landlord and animal control records."

3. Substantial Physical Damage

• Animal would cause damage that cannot be reduced or eliminated through reasonable conditions
• Must be based on objective evidence about this specific animal, not species

Example: Livestock, large exotic animals that would damage flooring/walls

Cannot deny based on:

• General concerns about damage
• Species alone (e.g., "all birds make too much mess")
• Normal wear and tear

4. Undue Financial or Administrative Burden

• Rare; usually only applies to very small landlords
• Must be significant burden relative to landlord's resources
• Individual landlord with one property may have more ability to claim this than large [property management](/blog/property-management-complete-guide) company

5. Fundamental Alteration

• Would fundamentally change the nature of operations
• Extremely rare in housing context

6. Property-Specific Restrictions

• Some jurisdictions prohibit certain animals entirely (exotic animals, livestock)
• Landlord cannot allow what local law prohibits

Invalid Reasons to Deny

❌ "We have a no-pets policy" - Assistance animals are not pets

❌ "Insurance doesn't allow that breed" - Generally not sufficient; seek alternative insurance or policy exception

❌ "Other tenants are afraid of dogs" - Not a valid reason without evidence of actual threat

❌ "The animal is too large" - Size alone is not a valid reason

❌ "We don't allow [species]" - Cannot discriminate by species for assistance animals

❌ "You can have a fish instead" - Tenant's healthcare provider determines what animal is needed

❌ "The building has a weight limit for pets" - Assistance animals are not subject to pet restrictions

Conditions You Can Impose

While you cannot charge pet deposits or pet rent, you CAN:

Require Tenant Responsibility

• Tenant must maintain control of animal (leash, carrier when appropriate)
• Tenant must clean up after animal
• Tenant must prevent animal from disturbing others
• Tenant is financially responsible for damage caused by animal

Enforce Behavior Standards

• Animal cannot be aggressive or threatening
• Cannot create unreasonable noise disturbances
• Must be housebroken/not create sanitation issues
• Must comply with local animal licensing and vaccination requirements

Hold Tenant Liable for Damages

• Can charge tenant for damage caused by assistance animal
• Can deduct from security deposit (or bill tenant) for damage beyond normal wear and tear
• Can evict for lease violations related to animal behavior

Require Documentation Updates

• Can require annual recertification for ESAs (to confirm ongoing disability-related need)
• Cannot require this for service animals

What You CANNOT Charge

❌ Pet deposit - Illegal for assistance animals

❌ Pet rent - Illegal for assistance animals

❌ Additional security deposit - Cannot increase deposit due to assistance animal

❌ Administrative or application fees for processing accommodation request

❌ Higher rent due to presence of assistance animal

What you CAN do: Charge tenant for actual damage, same as you would charge any tenant for damage they cause.

Multiple Animals or Exotic Animals

Multiple Animals

• Tenant may need more than one assistance animal
• Each animal requires separate verification
• Must demonstrate disability-related need for each specific animal
• Landlord can question whether multiple animals are needed or if one could suffice

Exotic or Unusual Animals

• Species doesn't automatically disqualify (pigs, reptiles, birds can be ESAs)
• Must verify disability-related need
• Can deny if animal poses health/safety threat specific to that species
• Local ordinances prohibiting certain species may allow denial
• Can require verification that animal is permitted under local law

Example: Miniature horse as service animal (specifically allowed under ADA in some circumstances), therapy pig as ESA (may be valid with proper documentation).

Special Situations

Condo and HOA Communities

• Fair Housing Act applies equally to HOAs and condos
• HOA pet restrictions must yield to assistance animal accommodations
• Individual unit owners must comply with FHA

Roommate Situations

• If you rent rooms in owner-occupied building with 4 or fewer units, FHA may not apply
• State/local laws may still require accommodations
• Best practice: comply with FHA anyway to avoid discrimination claims

Sale of Property

• New owner inherits obligation to continue accommodation
• Tenant doesn't need to reapply unless documentation is legitimately outdated

Military Housing

• Same rules apply
• Service members with disabilities have same rights to assistance animals

Documentation Best Practices

For Every Request:

1. Log the request - Date, time, method (oral/written)
2. Request documentation in writing (for ESAs)
3. Verify provider credentials - Check state licensing board
4. Evaluate request using consistent criteria
5. Respond in writing within reasonable time (10-14 days)
6. Keep all records - Requests, documentation, decisions, communications
7. Train staff - Everyone who interacts with tenants must understand rules

Sample Documentation File:

• Tenant's accommodation request
• Documentation from healthcare provider (for ESA)
• Your verification of provider credentials
• Your written decision (approval or denial with reasoning)
• Any correspondence about the accommodation
• Photos of animal (optional but helpful)
• License/vaccination records (can require compliance with local law)

Related Articles

• [Eviction Process State Guide](/blog/eviction-process-state-guide)
• [Fair Housing Landlord Guide](/blog/fair-housing-landlord-guide)
• [[Handling Difficult Tenants](/blog/handling-difficult-tenants-guide) Guide](/blog/handling-difficult-tenants-guide)
• [Homeowners Insurance Guide 2026](/blog/homeowners-insurance-guide-2026)
• How To Handle Eviction

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I require the tenant to pay for a pet deposit for an emotional support animal? A: No. Assistance animals are not pets. You cannot charge pet deposits, pet rent, or additional security deposits. However, you can charge the tenant for any damage the animal causes.

Q: A tenant showed me an ESA certificate from an online registry. Is that sufficient? A: No. Online registries and certificates are not valid documentation. You need a letter from a licensed healthcare provider with whom the tenant has an established treating relationship.

Q: What if my homeowner's insurance won't cover certain dog breeds? A: Insurance breed restrictions are generally not sufficient reason to deny an assistance animal under Fair Housing law. Contact your insurance company about policy exceptions or find alternative insurance. Some states require insurers to make exceptions for assistance animals.

Q: Can I require the emotional support animal to be spayed/neutered? A: This is a gray area. You can enforce requirements that apply to all animals under local law (licensing, vaccinations), but spay/neuter requirements for assistance animals specifically may be challenged as unreasonable conditions.

Q: The tenant's ESA letter is from an online service. Can I deny it? A: If the letter is from a licensed provider with no legitimate treating relationship (ESA mill), you can request proper documentation from a provider with an established relationship. Don't outright deny—engage in the interactive process and explain what documentation you need.

Q: Can I meet the animal before approving the request? A: You can request to verify the animal exists and is the type described in the documentation, but you cannot require behavior demonstrations or training tests. If you have specific concerns about a direct threat, those must be based on documented behavior, not a pre-approval evaluation.

Q: A tenant wants a snake as an ESA. Do I have to allow it? A: If the tenant provides proper documentation of disability and disability-related need for that specific animal, you generally must allow it unless local law prohibits the species or the animal poses a direct threat/substantial damage risk. Evaluate each request individually.

Q: Can I require proof the animal is housebroken? A: You cannot require advance proof, but you can require that all animals (including assistance animals) not create sanitation issues. If the animal repeatedly eliminates in inappropriate places, that's a legitimate lease violation.

Q: What if another tenant is allergic to the ESA? A: Both tenants have legitimate accommodation requests. You may need to make accommodations for both (HEPA filters, separating tenants in different buildings/units, additional cleaning). You generally cannot deny one tenant's animal due to another tenant's allergies without exploring all [alternatives](/blog/heloc-alternatives).

Q: Can I limit the ESA to certain areas (e.g., not allowed in common areas)? A: Generally no. Assistance animals must be allowed anywhere the tenant is allowed to go, just like any service animal. The animal must have same access as tenant to all common areas.

---

Navigating assistance animal requests requires balancing tenant rights with landlord protections. When in doubt, engage in the interactive process, document everything, and consult with a Fair Housing attorney. The penalties for wrongful denial can be substantial, but you also have legitimate rights to verify requests and deny animals that pose genuine threats. The key is following the proper process and basing decisions on objective evidence, not assumptions or stereotypes.