Reverse Mortgage Pros and Cons: An Honest Assessment

Few financial products generate as much confusion — and as many strong opinions — as reverse mortgages. Advocates call them a lifeline for cash-strapped retirees. Critics call them predatory traps that drain family wealth. Late-night TV ads make them sound like free money.

The truth is more nuanced than any of these positions. A reverse mortgage is a legitimate financial tool that works well in specific situations and poorly in others. This guide strips away the marketing and the fear-mongering to give you an honest assessment of how they work, what they cost, and whether one might make sense for you.

How a Reverse Mortgage Actually Works

A reverse mortgage — formally called a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM) when federally insured — allows homeowners age 62 or older to borrow against their home equity without making monthly mortgage payments.

Instead of you paying the bank each month (like a traditional mortgage), the bank pays you. The loan balance grows over time as interest accrues on the amount you've borrowed. The loan becomes due when you sell the home, move out permanently, or pass away.

The Mechanics

1. You apply through an FHA-approved lender. You must own your home outright or have a small remaining mortgage balance (which gets paid off from the reverse mortgage proceeds).

2. A counselor reviews your situation. HUD requires mandatory counseling from an independent, HUD-approved counseling agency before you can proceed. This isn't optional — it's a consumer protection measure.

3. Your home is appraised to determine current market value.

4. You receive funds based on your age, home value, current interest rates, and the HECM lending limits (currently $1,209,750 as of 2025). Older borrowers with more valuable homes and lower interest rates qualify for more.

5. You choose how to receive the money:

• Lump sum: One-time payment (only available with fixed-rate HECMs)
• Monthly payments: Fixed amount for a set term or for as long as you live in the home
• Line of credit: Draw funds as needed, with the unused portion growing over time
• Combination: Mix of monthly payments and line of credit

6. No monthly payments required. You must continue paying property taxes, homeowners insurance, and maintaining the home. Failure to do so is the primary cause of reverse mortgage defaults.

7. The loan comes due when the last surviving borrower sells, moves out for 12+ consecutive months, or dies.

How Much Can You Borrow?

The amount depends on the principal limit factor (PLF), which varies by age and interest rate. As a rough guide:

• Age 62: ~40-50% of home value
• Age 70: ~50-58% of home value
• Age 75: ~55-63% of home value
• Age 80: ~60-68% of home value
• Age 85+: ~65-75% of home value

On a $400,000 home, a 72-year-old borrower might access $200,000-$230,000. These are approximate — actual amounts vary by lender and current rates.

The Pros: When Reverse Mortgages Help

1. Eliminates Monthly Mortgage Payments

If you still carry a traditional mortgage, a reverse mortgage pays it off. For a retiree spending $1,500-$2,500/month on mortgage payments from a fixed income, this is transformational. That cash flow immediately becomes available for living expenses, healthcare, or quality of life.

2. Provides Income Without Selling Your Home

This is the core value proposition. You access equity — potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars — while continuing to live in your home for as long as you want. No moving, no downsizing, no disrupting your life.

For retirees who are "house rich and cash poor" (significant home equity but limited liquid savings), this solves a genuine problem that other financial tools can't.

3. The Line of Credit Growth Feature

This is the most underappreciated feature of HECMs. The unused portion of a reverse mortgage line of credit grows over time at the same rate as the loan's interest rate plus the mortgage insurance premium rate. In practice, this means the amount you can borrow increases each year — regardless of what happens to your home's value.

Example: You establish a $200,000 line of credit at age 65 but don't use it. At a growth rate of 5.5%, that credit line grows to approximately $345,000 by age 75 and $595,000 by age 85. You've created a growing financial reserve without any cost (you only pay interest on funds you actually draw).

Financial planners increasingly recommend establishing a HECM line of credit early in retirement — not to use immediately, but as a standby reserve for future needs (healthcare costs, market downturns, longevity risk).

4. Non-Recourse Protection

HECMs are non-recourse loans, meaning you (or your heirs) will never owe more than the home is worth at the time the loan is repaid. If your loan balance grows to $350,000 but the home is only worth $300,000 when you die, your heirs aren't on the hook for the $50,000 difference. FHA insurance covers the shortfall.

This is significant downside protection. In a housing market crash, you can't end up underwater in the way traditional mortgage borrowers can.

5. Tax-Free Proceeds

Reverse mortgage proceeds are not income — they're loan proceeds. They're not taxable. They don't affect your Social Security benefits. They don't count toward Medicare premium surcharges (IRMAA). This makes them one of the most tax-efficient ways to access cash in retirement.

6. Flexible Payment Options

The ability to choose between a lump sum, monthly payments, line of credit, or combination gives retirees flexibility to match their specific needs. Need to pay off a mortgage? Lump sum. Want supplemental monthly income? Term or tenure payments. Want a safety net? Line of credit.

7. Coordination With Other Retirement Strategies

Sophisticated financial planning uses reverse mortgages to:

• Delay Social Security. Draw from the HECM to cover expenses from age 62-70, allowing Social Security benefits to grow 8% per year. A $2,000/month benefit at 62 becomes roughly $3,500/month at 70.
• Avoid selling investments in down markets. Instead of selling stocks at a loss during a market downturn, draw from the HECM until the market recovers. This "buffer asset" strategy can significantly improve portfolio longevity.
• Fund in-home care. Long-term care insurance is expensive and increasingly hard to obtain. An HECM provides a pool of funds specifically for aging-in-place care.

The Cons: When Reverse Mortgages Hurt

1. High Upfront Costs

HECMs are expensive to establish:

• FHA mortgage insurance premium (MIP): 2% of the appraised home value (up to the HECM limit). On a $400,000 home, that's $8,000 — paid at closing.
• Origination fee: Up to $6,000 (2% of the first $200,000 of home value + 1% of value above $200,000, capped at $6,000).
• Third-party closing costs: Appraisal, title search, recording fees, etc. — typically $2,000-$4,000.
• Ongoing MIP: 0.5% annually on the outstanding loan balance, added to the loan.
• Interest: Variable rates currently in the 6-8% range (fixed rates available for lump-sum only, typically slightly higher).

Total upfront costs on a $400,000 home: $12,000-$18,000. These are usually rolled into the loan balance, so you don't pay out of pocket — but they reduce the equity available to you.

2. Compound Interest Erodes Equity Rapidly

This is the biggest financial risk. Because you're not making payments, interest compounds on the growing loan balance. A $200,000 draw at 7% interest becomes:

• After 5 years: ~$280,000
• After 10 years: ~$394,000
• After 15 years: ~$552,000
• After 20 years: ~$774,000

If the home appreciates at 3% annually during the same period, a $400,000 home is worth approximately $723,000 in 20 years. The loan balance ($774,000) exceeds the home value. The non-recourse protection means your heirs aren't liable for the difference, but there's zero equity left to inherit.

This is the core trade-off: current income versus future inheritance. It's not wrong — it's a conscious choice. But the math should be fully understood before making it.

3. Property Tax and Insurance Obligations Continue

The #1 reason reverse mortgages go into default: borrowers fail to pay property taxes or maintain homeowners insurance. The loan servicer can (and will) call the loan due, potentially forcing a sale.

For retirees who are already struggling to pay property taxes, a reverse mortgage may provide temporary relief but doesn't solve the underlying cash flow problem — especially in states with rapidly rising property tax assessments.

HUD now requires lenders to conduct a financial assessment and may require a "Life Expectancy Set-Aside" (LESA) — funds set aside from your HECM proceeds specifically to cover future tax and insurance payments. This protects you but reduces the amount you can access.

4. Impact on Heirs

This is often the most emotionally charged issue. Your children or other heirs may be expecting to inherit the family home or its equity. A reverse mortgage can significantly reduce or eliminate that inheritance.

When the last borrower passes away, heirs have options:

• Pay off the loan balance (through refinancing or other funds) and keep the home
• Sell the home and keep any equity above the loan balance
• Walk away if the loan balance exceeds the home value (no liability to heirs)

Heirs get 30 days after notification of the borrower's death to declare their intent, and up to 6 months (with possible extensions to 12 months) to complete the sale or payoff. The timeline can be stressful for families dealing with grief.

Open communication with heirs before taking a reverse mortgage prevents surprises and resentment.

5. Reduced Flexibility for Future Moves

If your health declines and you need to move to assisted living, the reverse mortgage becomes due. You'll sell the home and pay off the loan balance from proceeds. But if the loan balance has grown substantially and the market hasn't appreciated enough, there may be little equity left to fund your care.

Similarly, if you want to relocate for any reason (closer to family, different climate, smaller space), you're selling with a loan balance that may have consumed much of your equity.

6. Complexity and Confusion

Despite mandatory counseling, many borrowers don't fully understand reverse mortgage terms. The variable interest rates, growing loan balances, MIP calculations, and various payout options create a product that's inherently complex.

This complexity has historically attracted bad actors. While FHA regulation has improved significantly since the program's early days, retirees should still approach reverse mortgage advertising and unsolicited offers with healthy skepticism.

7. Opportunity Cost

Every dollar borrowed against your home is a dollar of equity that could have been accessed differently — potentially at lower cost:

• HELOC: Lower closing costs, interest-only payments, but requires income to qualify and has variable rates
• Cash-out refinance: Fixed rate available, but requires monthly payments
• Downsizing: Frees equity completely with no ongoing interest costs
• Rental income: Renting a room or ADU generates income without borrowing

The reverse mortgage makes sense when these alternatives don't work. But if you can qualify for a HELOC or generate rental income, those options are usually cheaper.

Who Should Seriously Consider a Reverse Mortgage

Based on the pros and cons above, a HECM is most appropriate for retirees who:

1. Are 70+ years old (the older you are, the more you can borrow and the less time for compound interest to erode equity)
2. Plan to stay in their home long-term (5+ years minimum, ideally permanently)
3. Have substantial home equity ($200,000+) but limited liquid savings
4. Can comfortably afford property taxes and insurance from existing income
5. Have no strong desire to leave the home to heirs — or have had honest conversations with heirs about priorities
6. Have explored and eliminated cheaper alternatives (HELOC, downsizing, rental income)
7. Want a standby line of credit for emergencies, healthcare, or market downturn protection (even without immediate financial need)

Who Should Avoid a Reverse Mortgage

1. Retirees under 65 — too much time for compound interest to consume equity, and lower borrowing limits
2. People who may need to move soon — the costs don't make sense for short time horizons
3. Couples where one spouse is significantly younger — the non-borrowing spouse can face complications (though protections have improved)
4. Homeowners who can't afford taxes and insurance — the reverse mortgage won't solve the problem and may accelerate foreclosure risk
5. Anyone being pressured — by family members, financial advisors with conflicts of interest, or contractors selling home improvements
6. People with Medicaid needs — reverse mortgage proceeds can affect Medicaid eligibility if not spent within the month received (the rules are complex and state-specific)

The Numbers: A Detailed Scenario

Let's trace a realistic reverse mortgage through a 20-year retirement:

Borrower: 72-year-old widow. Home value: $450,000. No existing mortgage.

HECM terms: $245,000 available (55% PLF). Chooses line of credit. Variable rate at 6.5% (including MIP).

Upfront costs (rolled into loan):

• MIP: $9,000
• Origination: $4,500
• Closing costs: $3,000
• Total: $16,500

Usage pattern:

• Year 1-5: Draws $1,000/month ($60,000 total) for supplemental income
• Year 6-10: Draws $1,500/month ($90,000 total) as healthcare costs rise
• Year 11-15: Draws $2,000/month ($120,000 total) for in-home care assistance
• Total drawn over 15 years: $270,000

Wait — that exceeds her $245,000 limit. Not exactly. Remember the line of credit growth feature. The unused portion has been growing at roughly 6.5% annually. By drawing gradually instead of all at once, the available credit grows ahead of her draws. In practice, she may be able to draw $250,000-$280,000 over 15 years.

At year 15 (age 87):

• Total drawn: ~$270,000
• Accrued interest and MIP: ~$180,000
• Loan balance: ~$450,000
• Home value (3% annual appreciation): ~$700,000
• Remaining equity: ~$250,000

At year 20 (age 92):

• Loan balance (if no further draws, interest continues): ~$630,000
• Home value: ~$812,000
• Remaining equity: ~$182,000

She lived in her home for 20 years, received $270,000 in supplemental income, funded her own in-home care, and still left $182,000 in equity for her heirs. Without the reverse mortgage, she might have run out of money, been forced into a Medicaid-funded facility, or burdened her children with her care costs.

That's the reverse mortgage working as intended.

Questions to Ask a Reverse Mortgage Lender

If you're considering a HECM, these questions help you evaluate the offer:

1. What is the total cost of the loan (upfront MIP + origination + closing costs)?
2. What is the initial interest rate and margin (for variable-rate loans)?
3. What is the principal limit factor for my age and interest rate?
4. Is a LESA required for taxes and insurance? If so, how much is set aside?
5. What are the exact conditions that trigger the loan becoming due?
6. What happens if I need to enter a nursing facility for more than 12 months?
7. What protections exist for a non-borrowing spouse?
8. Can I make voluntary payments to reduce the loan balance?
9. What is the process and timeline for heirs after my death?
10. What are the current market alternatives (HELOC rates, cash-out refi terms)?

FAQs

Can the bank take my home with a reverse mortgage?

No — as long as you meet the loan obligations (live in the home, pay property taxes, maintain insurance, keep the property in reasonable condition). You retain title and ownership throughout the loan. The bank cannot force a sale while you're living in the home and meeting these requirements.

What happens when I die — do my heirs owe the debt?

No. HECMs are non-recourse. Heirs can either pay off the loan balance and keep the home, sell the home and keep equity above the loan balance, or walk away with no liability. If the loan balance exceeds the home's value, FHA insurance covers the difference — the lender can't pursue heirs for the shortfall.

Can I still leave my home to my children?

Yes, but with a lien attached. Your heirs inherit the home subject to the reverse mortgage balance. They can keep the home by paying off the loan (through a traditional mortgage, savings, or other funds). If they can't or don't want to pay, they sell the home and keep any remaining equity.

How do reverse mortgage interest rates compare to traditional mortgages?

HECM rates are typically 1-2% higher than traditional mortgage rates, plus the 0.5% annual MIP. As of early 2026, variable HECM rates run approximately 6-8% depending on the lender and index. Fixed rates are available only for lump-sum disbursements and are generally higher.

Will a reverse mortgage affect my Social Security or Medicare?

No. Reverse mortgage proceeds are loan proceeds, not income. They don't affect Social Security benefits, Medicare eligibility, or Medicare premiums. However, if you receive Medicaid (not Medicare), reverse mortgage proceeds retained beyond the month of receipt could be counted as assets and affect eligibility. Consult a benefits counselor if you receive or may need Medicaid.

Can I pay off a reverse mortgage early?

Yes, at any time, with no prepayment penalty. You can make partial or full payments whenever you want. Some retirees establish a HECM line of credit as a safety net but never draw from it — or draw during market downturns and repay when their portfolio recovers.

Are there alternatives to the FHA HECM program?

Yes. Proprietary (private) reverse mortgages exist for homes valued above the HECM limit. These "jumbo" reverse mortgages can access equity on homes worth $1 million to $10 million+. They don't carry FHA insurance, which means different (sometimes lower) upfront costs but also fewer consumer protections. They're worth exploring if your home exceeds the HECM limit.

The Bottom Line

A reverse mortgage is neither the miracle solution the TV ads promise nor the predatory trap the critics warn about. It's a financial tool — expensive, complex, and powerful in the right circumstances.

The right circumstances: a retiree who wants to stay home, needs the income, has limited alternatives, and understands the trade-off between current cash flow and future equity.

The wrong circumstances: a retiree who's being sold a reverse mortgage by someone who profits from the transaction, doesn't fully understand the terms, or has better options available.

Get the mandatory counseling. Run the numbers honestly. Talk to your family. And make the decision based on your actual situation — not a TV commercial and not someone else's horror story.

Related Articles

• [Home Equity Explained: What It Is and How to Build It](/blog/home-equity-explained)
• Property Taxes Explained: How They Work and How to Reduce Them
• Blended Family Home Planning: Merging Households and Managing Home Equity