Property Tax Appeal Step-by-Step: How to Fight Your Assessment and Win

Here's a fact most [homeowners](/blog/home-insurance-savings) don't know: roughly 30%–60% of all properties in the U.S. are over-assessed, meaning owners pay more property tax than they legally owe. And the people who benefit most are the ones who appeal.

According to the National Taxpayers Union, homeowners who appeal their property tax assessments succeed in getting a reduction approximately 50% of the time — often saving hundreds or even thousands of dollars per year. The process takes a few hours of research and paperwork. The potential reward is substantial.

This step-by-step guide shows you exactly how to build and file a winning property tax appeal.

Understanding How Property Taxes Work

Before appealing, understand the system you're working within.

The Assessment Process: Your county assessor (or a contracted assessment company) estimates the value of your property — called the "assessed value." Your tax bill is calculated by multiplying this value by your local tax rate (mill rate):

Annual Property Tax = Assessed Value × Mill Rate

The assessed value is often a percentage of "fair market value" — some counties assess at 100% of market value; others assess at 70%, 80%, or other percentages. This varies by state and locality.

The appeal opportunity: Over-assessments happen for three main reasons:

1. Mass appraisal errors: Assessors evaluate thousands of properties using automated systems and comparable sales, making mistakes common
2. Failure to capture condition or defects: Assessors typically don't interior-inspect every home
3. Market lag: In falling markets, assessments may not reflect current market conditions

Step 1: Review Your Assessment Notice Carefully

Your county mails an assessment notice (typically annually or biannually). Don't throw it away. Read it carefully:

• What is the assessed value?
• What is the effective tax rate applied?
• What is your calculated annual tax bill?
• What is the appeal deadline? (Critical — missing this date ends your options for the year)

Where to find it: If you didn't receive your notice or misplaced it, your county assessor's website almost always has an online property lookup tool where you can view your current assessment.

Step 2: Check Your Assessment Record for Errors

Before building a market value argument, check for factual errors in your assessment record. These are common and easy to fix.

Access your full property record at your county assessor's website. Verify:

Basic information:

• Square footage (measured incorrectly — too large?)
• Lot size
• Number of bedrooms and bathrooms
• Garage (1-car assessed as 2-car?)
• Basement (finished or unfinished accurately noted?)
• Year built

Property improvements overstated:

• Is the assessor assuming features you don't have (e.g., a pool you don't have)?
• Is square footage overstated due to including an unheated garage or porch?

Property condition:

• Does the record show "good" or "excellent" condition when the home has significant deferred maintenance?

If you find factual errors, document them with photographs and measurements. Correcting a data error is the easiest appeal to win — it's simply fixing a mistake, not arguing about opinion.

Step 3: Determine Your Property's Fair Market Value

This is the heart of your appeal: you need to demonstrate that your home is worth less than the assessor claims.

Primary method: Comparable Sales ("Comps")

The strongest evidence is recent sales of similar homes in your neighborhood that sold for less than the assessor's estimated value implies.

How to find comps:

• Zillow: Use the "Recently Sold" filter in your neighborhood (filter for last 6–12 months)
• Redfin: Sold homes search with filters for bedrooms, bathrooms, and square footage
• County tax records: All property sales are public record
• Ask a real estate agent: Many agents will pull comp data for free in hopes of earning your future business

What makes a good comp:

• Same neighborhood (within 0.5–1 mile)
• Similar size (within 10%–15% of your square footage)
• Similar age and condition
• Sold within the last 6–12 months (assessors typically use a valuation date in the prior year)
• Similar lot size

Build your case: If you can find 3–5 comparable homes that sold for less than your assessment implies, you have a strong case. The argument: "The market says homes like mine are worth $X, but the assessor says $Y — here's the proof."

Step 4: Calculate Your Over-Assessment Amount

Now quantify the discrepancy between what the assessor says your home is worth and what comparable sales suggest.

Example:

• Assessor's estimated market value: $485,000
• Average of 5 comparable recent sales: $430,000
• Over-assessment amount: $55,000
• Your local tax rate: 1.2%
• Annual tax overcharge: $55,000 × 1.2% = $660/year

This is what you're fighting for. Over 10 years, that's $6,600 in excess taxes (assuming the assessment gap persists).

Step 5: Understand Your County's Specific Process

Every county has its own appeal process, forms, deadlines, and hearing procedures. Research yours before proceeding.

Key information to find:

• Appeal deadline: Most counties have deadlines of 30–90 days after notices are mailed. Missing this date means waiting another year.
• Forms required: Most counties have specific appeal/complaint forms available on the assessor's website
• Filing fee: Some counties charge a small fee ($25–$100); many are free
• Process type: Some counties offer informal review (meet with assessor's staff); others go straight to a formal board hearing

Contact your county assessor's office directly if anything is unclear. They're generally helpful — they deal with this every year.

Step 6: Prepare Your Evidence Package

Whether you attend an informal review or formal hearing, you need organized, professional [documentation](/blog/heloc-documentation-requirements).

Your evidence package should include:

1. Completed appeal form with your contact information, assessment details, and requested value

2. Comparable sales grid (table format works well):

3. Photographs of condition issues, deferred maintenance, or defects that reduce value

4. Repair estimates if there are structural or system issues affecting value

5. Copy of your recent home inspection report (if it documented significant issues)

6. Printed comp listings from Zillow or Redfin showing sale price and property details

Keep everything organized in a folder. You'll submit copies and keep originals.

Step 7: File Your Appeal Before the Deadline

Submit your appeal form (with any required filing fee) before the deadline. Options typically include:

• Online submission (many counties now offer this)
• Mail (certified mail recommended — keep your receipt)
• In-person at the assessor's office

After filing, you'll receive a confirmation and a date for your informal review or formal hearing.

Step 8: The Informal Review (If Offered)

Many counties offer an informal step where you meet with an assessor's staff member to present your evidence before going to a formal hearing board. This is often the easiest path to resolution:

How to handle it:

• Present your evidence calmly and professionally
• Lead with factual errors (if any) before market value arguments
• Let the comps speak for themselves — don't editorialize
• Ask what reduction they can offer
• Be open to a partial reduction (a partial win is still a win)

If the informal review results in a satisfactory reduction, you may not need to proceed to a formal hearing. Get any reduction in writing.

Step 9: The Formal Board Hearing

If the informal review doesn't resolve it, or if your county goes straight to formal hearings, here's what to expect:

The hearing panel: Typically a local Board of Equalization, Assessment Review Board, or similar body. Panel members are often appointed local residents — not technical appraisal experts.

Your presentation:

• You'll have 5–15 minutes (varies by jurisdiction)
• Start with factual errors if relevant
• Present your comp grid — let the numbers make the argument
• Keep it professional and brief
• Bring extra copies of all evidence for the panel members

What NOT to do:

• Don't make emotional arguments ("My neighbor pays less than me")
• Don't argue that taxes are too high in general
• Don't attack the assessor personally
• Don't arrive without organized evidence

The decision: Some boards rule the same day; others mail their decision later. If you're not satisfied with the outcome, many states have a further appeal path to tax court.

Step 10: If You Win, Verify the Correction

After a successful appeal, verify that:

• Your assessment has been updated in the county records
• Your subsequent tax bills reflect the corrected value
• The correction applies to all future tax years (not just the one you appealed)

Some counties adjust retroactively (refunding overpaid taxes); others apply the reduction going forward only.

Professional Help: When to Hire a Property Tax Consultant

For most homeowners, a DIY appeal is entirely feasible. But consider hiring a property tax consultant or attorney if:

• Your over-assessment is substantial ($1,000+/year in excess taxes)
• You own commercial or investment property with complex valuation issues
• You've already lost at the board level and are considering tax court

Most tax consultants work on contingency — they charge 25%–50% of your first year's savings. You pay nothing if you lose. This aligns incentives well and makes professional help accessible.

For investment property owners, property tax savings also improve your DSCR ratio — an important factor in [[DSCR loan](/blog/dscr-loan-guide) eligibility and refinancing](/blog/dscr-loan-refinance-guide).

Special Situations That Strengthen Your Appeal

Recent purchase below assessment: If you recently bought your home for less than the assessed value, your purchase price is powerful evidence of fair market value — it's an arm's-length transaction proving what a willing buyer paid.

Significant deferred maintenance: Assessors rarely see the inside of homes. If your home has serious issues (outdated electrical, old HVAC, structural issues), document and price them.

Unfavorable location factors: Did the assessor account for proximity to a highway, commercial property, flood zone status, or other value-reducing features your comps don't share?

Recent decline in neighborhood values: If your neighborhood has seen falling prices since the assessment date (as happens in correction periods), comps during the relevant period support a lower value.

What to Do If You Lose

A denied appeal isn't the end of the road:

• Request the assessor's evidence and methodology in writing
• Identify weaknesses in their analysis for next year's appeal
• File again when you have stronger evidence
• Consider whether an independent appraisal would support a stronger case
• Explore whether your state allows a further appeal to state tax court

Also: even if you lose this year's appeal, the research you did positions you perfectly for next year. Property tax appeals are a recurring annual opportunity.

---

Related Articles

• [[Homestead Exemption](/blog/homestead-exemption-guide): How to Apply](/blog/homestead-exemption-how-to-apply)
• [[Property Tax Guide](/blog/property-tax-guide)](/blog/property-tax-guide)
• [Challenging [Property Assessment](/blog/real-estate-due-diligence-checklist)](/blog/challenging-property-assessment)
• [[Home Appraisal](/blog/appraisal-process-explained) vs. Property Assessment](/blog/home-appraisal-vs-assessment)
• Market Value vs. Assessed Value
• [[DSCR Loan Refinance](/blog/dscr-loan-refinance-guide) Guide](/blog/dscr-loan-refinance-guide)