Adding a Pool to Your Home: Costs, ROI, and Honest Advice

A backyard pool sounds dreamy. Lazy summer days. Kids playing. Evening swims after work.

Then you see the price tag and wonder: Is this actually worth it?

Let's be honest about pools—the real costs, the real ROI (often negative), and when it actually makes sense.

Pool Costs: The Full Picture

Installation Costs by Type

Inground Concrete (Gunite/Shotcrete)

• Base cost: $50,000-100,000+
• Most customizable, most durable, most expensive
• Lasts 50+ years with proper maintenance
• Any shape, size, depth

Inground Fiberglass

• Base cost: $40,000-75,000
• Pre-molded shell, faster installation
• Limited shapes/sizes
• Smooth surface, lower chemical needs
• Lasts 25-30+ years

Inground Vinyl Liner

• Base cost: $35,000-65,000
• Cheapest upfront, highest maintenance
• Liner replacement every 5-10 years ($4,000-8,000)
• Most prone to damage

Above Ground

• Base cost: $3,000-15,000
• Budget option
• Looks budget
• Shorter lifespan (7-15 years)

The Real Cost Is Higher

That $60K quote? Budget $80-100K by the time you're done.

Ongoing Annual Costs

This is where pools really hurt:

Over 10 years, you'll spend $30,000-80,000+ just maintaining the pool.

True 10-year cost of ownership:

• Installation: $70,000
• Maintenance: $50,000
• Total: $120,000+

Pool ROI: The Uncomfortable Truth

What The Data Says

According to real estate studies:

• Pools add 0-7% to home value (varies hugely by market)
• Average added value: $20,000-40,000
• Installation cost: $60,000-100,000+

Translation: You'll likely lose $30,000-70,000 on the "investment."

Why Pools Have Negative ROI

1. Not everyone wants a pool - Some buyers see liability, maintenance, lost yard space
2. Regional variation - Pool in Minnesota? Liability. Pool in Phoenix? Expected.
3. Maintenance fear - Non-pool owners overestimate the hassle
4. Safety concerns - Families with young kids may avoid pool homes
5. Insurance - Higher premiums are a turn-off

When Pools DO Add Value

High-value markets in warm climates:

• Phoenix, Las Vegas, Miami, Palm Springs
• Pools are expected in luxury homes
• No pool can hurt resale

Custom luxury homes:

• $1M+ properties
• Pool is part of total package
• Adds proportionally more value

Rental/Airbnb properties:

• Pool can significantly increase rental rates
• Better ROI calculation (income vs. cost)

Should You Build a Pool?

Yes, If:

You'll actually use it

• You swim regularly
• Kids will use it for years
• You entertain often
• Climate supports 6+ months of use

You're staying long-term

• 10+ years in the home
• Cost spreads over many summers
• Not concerned about resale ROI

You can afford it comfortably

• Budget covers installation + 10 years maintenance
• Not using emergency fund
• Not stretching to finance

Your market values pools

• Warm climate
• Neighbors have pools
• Expected amenity in your tier

No, If:

You're focused on ROI

• Pools are lifestyle purchases, not investments
• You'll almost certainly lose money

You're planning to move

• 5 years or less
• Won't get your money back

You're stretching financially

• Using all available credit
• Would stress monthly budget
• No emergency fund

Climate doesn't support it

• 3-4 months of swim weather
• Pool sits covered most of year

Your yard is your sanctuary

• Pool dominates space
• Less room for gardens, play, entertaining

Pool Alternatives

Hot Tub/Spa

• Cost: $5,000-20,000 installed
• Year-round use
• Smaller footprint
• Easier maintenance

Swim Spa

• Cost: $20,000-40,000
• Hybrid pool/spa
• Swim current for exercise
• Smaller than pool

Natural Swimming Pool

• Cost: $70,000-150,000+
• Chlorine-free
• Looks like pond
• Eco-friendly
• High maintenance

Community Pool

• Cost: HOA dues
• No maintenance
• No liability
• Someone else's problem

Stock Tank Pool

• Cost: $500-2,000
• DIY project
• Instagram-friendly
• Small but functional

How to Finance a Pool

HELOC (Most Common)

• Access home equity
• Draw as needed during construction
• Interest-only payments available
• Rate: Prime + 0-2%
• Learn about HELOCs

Home Equity Loan

• Lump sum
• Fixed rate
• Fixed payments
• Good if you know exact cost

Pool Loan (Personal Loan)

• Unsecured
• Higher rate (8-15%)
• Faster approval
• No home equity needed

Dealer Financing

⚠️ Beware: Pool companies often push financing with high rates.

• Rates can be 12-18%
• May have hidden fees
• Shop financing separately

Example:

• $70,000 pool
• Dealer financing at 14%: $1,150/month for 10 years
• HELOC at 8%: $580/month interest-only

Difference: $29,400 over 10 years. Shop your own financing.

Cash

• Best if you have it
• No interest costs
• Full negotiating power with contractor

The Pool Building Process

Timeline: 3-6 months

Month 1: Planning

• Choose pool type and shape
• Get 3+ quotes
• Check permits and HOA rules
• Secure financing

Month 2: Permits

• Submit plans
• Wait for approval (2-6 weeks)
• Survey and utility marking

Month 3-4: Construction

• Excavation (1-3 days)
• Steel and plumbing (1 week)
• Shotcrete/shell (1-2 days for gunite)
• Curing time (1-2 weeks)
• Tile and coping (1 week)
• Decking (1-2 weeks)
• Equipment (1 week)

Month 5-6: Finishing

• Interior surface
• Fill and balance water
• Final inspections
• Landscaping

Questions to Ask Pool Contractors

1. What's included in the quote? (Excavation, permits, fencing, electrical?)
2. What's NOT included?
3. How long have you been in business?
4. Can I see recent projects and talk to owners?
5. What's the warranty on shell, equipment, surface?
6. Who handles permits?
7. What's the payment schedule?
8. What happens if we hit rock during excavation? (Cost overrun potential)
9. Do you use subcontractors or in-house crews?
10. What's the timeline and what causes delays?

The Honest Verdict

Pools are luxury items. Treat the decision that way.

If someone says "You'll make your money back when you sell"—they're probably wrong.

If someone says "Pools are money pits"—they're not wrong, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't get one.

The right question: Will the joy my family gets from this pool over the next 10-15 years be worth $100,000+?

For some families, absolutely yes. Summer memories are priceless. Kids who grow up swimming. Backyard entertaining. Daily exercise.

For others, that $100K builds college funds, funds retirement, or creates experiences through travel.

There's no wrong answer—just be honest about what you're buying and why.

---

Considering a pool? Get a HELOC quote to understand your home equity financing options—and avoid expensive dealer financing.