HELOC with Variable Income: Commission, Bonus, Freelance Guide

Getting approved for a HELOC is straightforward when you have predictable W-2 salary income. But what if you're a real estate agent earning 100% commission? A salesperson with significant bonus income? A freelancer or consultant with fluctuating client revenue? Variable income complicates HELOC approval, but it's far from impossible.

Why Variable Income Complicates HELOC Approval

HELOC lenders assess your ability to make monthly payments. Variable income introduces uncertainty:

Income Averaging Creates Lower Qualifying Amounts

Lenders don't use your best month or even best year. They average income over 12-24 months:

Example: Real estate agent

• Year 1: $95,000
• Year 2: $135,000
• Year 3 (partial): $82,000 (through 8 months, annualizes to ~$123,000)

Lender calculation: Often averages Year 1 and Year 2: ($95,000 + $135,000) ÷ 2 = $115,000 qualifying income

If the agent had consistent $135,000 salary, they'd qualify based on that full amount. Averaging reduces qualifying income.

Declining Income Trends Are Red Flags

If your income is trending downward, expect problems:

Example:

• Year 1: $140,000
• Year 2: $110,000
• Current year pace: $95,000

Lenders will likely use the lowest figure ($95,000) or deny the application entirely, assuming the decline will continue.

Documentation Requirements Multiply

Salaried employees provide pay stubs and W-2s. Variable income borrowers need:

• Two years of tax returns with all schedules
• Year-to-date profit & loss statements
• Bank statements showing deposits
• 1099 forms
• Explanations of income fluctuations
• Potentially CPA letters confirming income

More documentation = more scrutiny = higher denial rates.

Self-Employment Adds Another Layer

If your variable income comes from self-employment:

• Lenders typically require 2 years of business history
• Tax deductions reduce qualifying income
• Business structure (sole prop, LLC, S-corp) affects calculations
• Some lenders require business bank statements and financials

Types of Variable Income and How Lenders Treat Them

Not all variable income is treated equally:

Commission Income (W-2 Employee)

Examples: Real estate agents, car salespeople, financial advisors earning commissions from an employer

Lender treatment:

• Typically average last 2 years of commission income from W-2s and tax returns
• If you've received commissions for less than 2 years, some lenders require 1 year but may be more conservative
• Declining commission trend = major red flag
• Stable or increasing trend = favorable

Documentation:

• W-2s (2 years) showing base + commission breakdown
• Recent pay stubs (2-3 months)
• Tax returns (2 years) to verify W-2 income
• Letter from employer confirming commission structure and continuation

Best case scenario: You have 2+ years of stable/increasing commission income, documented consistently.

Bonus Income (W-2 Employee)

Examples: Annual bonuses, performance bonuses, quarterly incentives on top of base salary

Lender treatment:

• Requires 2-year history of receiving bonuses
• Averages last 2 years of bonuses
• Some lenders require employer letter confirming bonuses will continue
• More conservative lenders ignore bonuses entirely or count only 50%

Documentation:

• W-2s showing bonus income
• Pay stubs showing recent bonus payments
• Employer letter stating bonus is likely to continue

Key consideration: One-time bonuses or bonuses tied to specific projects won't count. Lenders want evidence of recurring bonus income.

Self-Employment Income (Sole Proprietor, LLC, Partnership)

Examples: Freelancers, consultants, contractors, small business owners

Lender treatment:

• Requires 2 years of self-employment tax returns (1040 with Schedule C or business returns)
• Calculates income after business expenses and deductions
• If you have business losses or declining income, denial is likely
• Many lenders add back non-cash expenses (depreciation, depletion) to income

Documentation:

• Personal tax returns with Schedule C (2 years)
• Business tax returns if incorporated (1065, 1120, 1120S)
• Year-to-date profit & loss statement
• Business bank statements (3-6 months)
• Business license or DBA registration
• CPA letter explaining income and business stability (helpful but not always required)

Calculation example:

• Gross business income: $180,000
• Business expenses: $65,000
• Depreciation (non-cash): $12,000
• Net income per Schedule C: $115,000
• Qualifying income: $115,000 + $12,000 (depreciation added back) = $127,000

Gig Economy/Multiple Income Streams

Examples: Uber/Lyft drivers, DoorDash, freelance platforms (Upwork, Fiverr), multiple part-time 1099 gigs

Lender treatment:

• Most conservative treatment
• Requires 2 years of documented 1099 income
• All income sources need to be documented separately
• Inconsistent or sporadic income often not counted
• Some lenders decline gig economy income entirely

Documentation:

• All 1099 forms (2 years)
• Tax returns showing all income sources
• Platform statements (Uber, DoorDash, etc.) showing earnings
• Bank statements showing deposits from all sources

Challenge: Gig income is often the most volatile. Lenders prefer stable, predictable income sources.

Investment Income (Dividends, Interest, Capital Gains)

Examples: Dividend income from stocks, interest from bonds, capital gains from trading

Lender treatment:

• Recurring investment income (dividends, interest) can count if documented for 2+ years
• Capital gains are typically not counted (too irregular)
• Must show likelihood of continuation (usually requires substantial asset base)

Documentation:

• Tax returns showing investment income (2 years)
• Brokerage statements showing dividend/interest-producing assets
• Documentation that assets will remain invested (not being liquidated)

Documentation Strategies for Variable Income Borrowers

Maximize your approval odds with thorough documentation:

Organize Tax Returns Properly

What to provide:

• Complete 1040 returns (all pages) for 2 years
• All schedules: Schedule C (self-employment), Schedule E (rental income), Schedule 1 (additional income)
• W-2s and 1099s matching tax return income

Common mistakes:

• Providing only 1040 form without schedules (instant denial)
• Incomplete returns (missing pages raise red flags)
• Unfiled returns (automatic disqualification)
• Amended returns without clear explanations

Prepare Year-to-Date Documentation

Even with 2 years of tax returns, lenders want current year information:

Profit & Loss Statement:

• Current year through most recent month
• Categorized income and expenses matching Schedule C format
• Signed and dated
• If prepared by CPA, have them sign

Bank statements:

• Business account statements (3-6 months)
• Personal account statements showing income deposits
• Highlight deposits corresponding to business income

Recent pay stubs (if W-2 with commissions/bonuses):

• Last 2-3 months showing year-to-date totals
• Match these to YTD P&L or income statements

Write Explanations for Irregularities

Lenders will ask about:

• Large fluctuations in income year-over-year
• Declining income trends
• Business losses in any year
• Gaps in employment or self-employment

Prepare written explanations:

• "2023 income was lower due to maternity leave from April-August. 2024 income returned to normal levels."
• "2022 showed business loss of $8,000 due to one-time equipment purchases ($15,000). Ongoing operations are profitable."
• "Commission income varies with [real estate market cycles](/blog/real-estate-market-cycle-timing). 2021-2023 averaged $125,000 annually with strong pipeline for 2024."

Get Third-Party Verification

CPA letters: Not always required, but can help:

• Confirms income calculations
• Explains non-cash deductions (depreciation)
• Verifies business is ongoing
• Addresses any tax return irregularities

Employer letters (for commission/bonus W-2 income):

• States your position and compensation structure
• Confirms commission/bonus income will continue
• Provides recent payment history
• Printed on company letterhead and signed

Show Business Stability

For self-employed applicants:

• Client contracts or ongoing work agreements
• Invoices showing consistent billings
• Business license and registrations
• Proof of business continuity (website, marketing materials, client testimonials)

Lenders Most Flexible with Variable Income

Not all lenders have identical policies:

Credit Unions

Often the best option for variable income borrowers:

• Relationship-based underwriting
• Will consider full story, not just numbers
• More likely to count recent income even without 2-year history
• Competitive rates

Strategy: Join credit union, establish banking relationship for 6-12 months before applying.

[Portfolio Lenders](/blog/portfolio-lending-guide) (Community Banks)

Banks that keep loans on their own books can be flexible:

• Customize underwriting for non-traditional income
• May accept 1 year of income history vs. 2 years
• Will consider income trends and explanations
• Require strong credit and substantial equity to compensate for income uncertainty

Specialized Lenders

Some lenders focus on self-employed and variable-income borrowers:

• Understand fluctuating income patterns
• More lenient with documentation
• Often allow "bank statement programs" (qualify based on deposits, not tax returns)
• Tradeoff: Higher interest rates (often 1-3% above standard HELOCs)

Traditional Banks (Least Flexible)

Wells Fargo, Chase, Bank of America:

• Strict adherence to 2-year income averaging
• Declining income = automatic denial
• Limited ability to consider explanations
• Best rates but hardest to qualify

When to try anyway: If you have 2+ years of stable/increasing variable income, excellent credit (740+), and low [debt-to-income ratio](/blog/dti-ratio-explained), big banks may offer the best rates.

Maximizing Qualifying Income

If your income is variable, strategic tax and financial planning helps:

Add Back Non-Cash Deductions

Self-employed borrowers can benefit from addbacks:

Common addbacks:

• Depreciation
• Depletion
• Amortization
• One-time business losses

Example:

• Net Schedule C income: $95,000
• Depreciation expense: $18,000
• Qualifying income: $113,000

Note: Lenders won't add back cash expenses like travel, supplies, or [contractor](/blog/diy-vs-contractor) payments—only non-cash accounting expenses.

Count All Eligible Income Sources

Don't forget to document:

• Part-time W-2 employment alongside self-employment
• Rental income from investment properties
• Alimony or child support (if it will continue 3+ years)
• Social Security, pension, disability income
• Investment income (dividends, interest)

Each additional income stream strengthens your application.

Timing Matters

Apply when income is strong:

• After a good year, not during a slump
• When year-to-date income matches or exceeds prior year
• After major deals close or big commission months

Avoid applying:

• During slow seasons (if your income is seasonal)
• Immediately after starting self-employment
• When current year is tracking below prior years

Consider Interim Business Income Strategies

If your tax returns show low income due to aggressive deductions:

Option 1: File next year's taxes showing higher income before applying for HELOC. Take fewer deductions to show more profit.

Option 2: Use a bank statement program lender (they qualify based on deposits, not tax returns). Expect higher rates.

Option 3: Wait another year to build better income history before applying.

Debt-to-Income Ratio Challenges

Variable income borrowers often struggle with DTI:

Calculation Differences

Fixed income borrower:

• Monthly income: $8,000
• Monthly debts: $2,800
• DTI: 35%

Variable income borrower:

• Average monthly income: $8,000 (but some months $5,000, others $12,000)
• Monthly debts: $2,800
• DTI: 35% on average, but 56% in slow months

Lenders calculate DTI on average income, but you need to manage cash flow during slow months.

Strategies to Improve DTI

Pay down debt before applying:

• Focus on minimum payments (credit cards, car loans)
• Consider paying off smaller debts entirely
• Refinance high-payment debts to lower monthly obligations

Increase income (if possible):

• Take on additional projects before applying
• Defer business expenses to reduce Schedule C expenses
• Realize bonuses or commissions before application

Lower HELOC request:

• Request smaller HELOC amount (lower estimated payment = lower DTI)
• You can often request increases later once approved

Real-World Example: Commission Income Approval

Borrower: Jennifer, real estate agent

• Income history:
  • 2022: $78,000 (first full year as agent)
  • 2023: $142,000 (strong market)
  • 2024 YTD: $98,000 (8 months = $147,000 annualized)
• Credit score: 710
• [Home value](/blog/appraisal-process-explained): $520,000
• Existing mortgage: $310,000
• HELOC goal: $75,000 for home renovations

First application (Bank of America):

• Calculated qualifying income: ($78,000 + $142,000) ÷ 2 = $110,000
• DTI with proposed HELOC: 41%
• Result: Denied due to income instability (large jump from Year 1 to Year 2)

Second application (local credit union):

• Jennifer provided:
  • W-2s for 2022-2023
  • YTD pay stubs showing $98,000 earned
  • Letter from broker showing her sales pipeline ($320,000 in pending commissions)
  • Explanation that 2022 was first year, income has stabilized at $140K+ level
• Credit union calculated qualifying income using 2023 + 2024 annualized average: ($142,000 + $147,000) ÷ 2 = $144,500
• DTI with proposed HELOC: 38%

Approval:

• HELOC amount: $70,000 (80% CLTV)
• Rate: Prime + 1.25%
• Required: 6 months of reserves (to cover slow months)

Key difference: Credit union considered her explanation and recent income trend, while big bank mechanically averaged years 1-2 without context.

Tax Planning for HELOC Approval

Self-employed borrowers face a dilemma:

The Tax Deduction vs. HELOC Approval Trade-off

Strategy 1: Maximize deductions (lowers taxes, lowers qualifying income)

• Take all legitimate business deductions
• Pay less tax
• Show lower net income on Schedule C
• Result: More tax savings, harder HELOC approval

Strategy 2: Minimize deductions (raises taxes, raises qualifying income)

• Defer or forgo certain deductions
• Pay more tax
• Show higher net income
• Result: Less tax savings, easier HELOC approval

Balanced approach:

• If you're planning to apply for a HELOC within 12-24 months, consider taking fewer discretionary deductions in the preceding tax year
• Focus on non-cash addbacks (depreciation) that lenders will add back anyway
• Time major equipment purchases after HELOC approval, not before

Working with Your CPA

Discuss HELOC plans with your accountant:

• They can structure your tax returns to optimize for lending while minimizing tax
• CPA letters explaining income can support your application
• They can help you calculate qualifying income the way lenders will

Alternative Documentation Programs

If traditional HELOC approval is difficult, consider alternative programs:

Bank Statement Programs

How they work:

• Lender analyzes 12-24 months of bank statements
• Calculates average monthly deposits
• Qualifies you based on deposit activity, not tax returns

Advantages:

• Don't need tax returns showing high income
• Works for borrowers with aggressive tax deductions
• Faster approval (less documentation)

Disadvantages:

• Higher interest rates (typically 2-4% above standard HELOCs)
• Lower LTV limits (often 70-75% max)
• Not all lenders offer these programs

Best for: Self-employed borrowers whose bank deposits significantly exceed reported tax return income.

Asset-Based Programs

How they work:

• Qualify based on assets (investment accounts, savings, retirement accounts)
• Lender verifies you have substantial assets to support HELOC payments
• Income still matters, but less emphasis

Advantages:

• Good for high-net-worth borrowers with variable income
• Retirees with limited income but substantial assets
• Less documentation of income sources

Disadvantages:

• Require significant assets (typically $500,000+ liquid assets)
• Higher rates and fees
• Limited lender availability

Stated Income Programs (Largely Discontinued)

Historical context: Before 2008, "stated income" or "no-doc" loans allowed borrowers to state their income without verification.

Current reality: These programs largely disappeared after the financial crisis. A few specialty lenders offer similar products with:

• Extensive asset documentation
• Higher rates (3-5% above standard)
• Much lower LTV (60-65% max)
• Typically for high-net-worth, excellent credit borrowers only

FAQ

How many years of variable income history do I need for a HELOC?

Most lenders require 2 years of consistent variable income documentation (tax returns, W-2s with commissions, etc.). Some credit unions and portfolio lenders will consider 1 year if you have excellent credit, substantial equity, and increasing income trends. Gig economy and self-employment income almost always require 2 years.

Can I qualify for a HELOC in my first year of self-employment?

It's very difficult. Most lenders require 2 years of self-employment tax returns. Exceptions exist if: you worked in the same field as a W-2 employee and recently went self-employed, you have exceptional credit (760+) and substantial home equity (60%+ equity), or you use specialized lenders with asset-based programs. Expect to wait until you have 2 years of tax returns.

Do lenders use my best year or average my income?

Lenders typically average your last 2 years of income. If your income is declining, they may use the lower/most recent year. If your income is increasing, averaging helps you. Some lenders give more weight to recent income if there's a clear upward trend and you can document why.

Will business deductions hurt my HELOC approval?

Cash business deductions (travel, supplies, contractor costs) reduce your qualifying income. Non-cash deductions like depreciation and depletion are often added back by lenders, increasing your qualifying income. Strategic tax planning can help—consult a CPA about optimizing your tax return for lending purposes if you plan to apply for a HELOC.

Can I use my spouse's income to qualify if mine is variable?

Yes. If your spouse has stable W-2 income, adding them as a co-borrower strengthens the application significantly. Lenders will combine your variable income with their stable income, making approval much more likely. Both spouses' credit and debts will be considered.

What if my income is increasing but I only have 1 year of history at the higher level?

Prepare documentation showing why the increase is sustainable: new clients, expanded business, promotion with higher commission structure, etc. Credit unions and portfolio lenders are more likely to consider this favorably than big banks. You may still need to wait for a second year of tax returns at the higher level for maximum approval odds.

Do I need to show profit every year as a self-employed borrower?

Yes. Business losses (negative Schedule C income) in any of the last 2 years will likely result in denial. If you had a loss in one year, prepare a thorough explanation (one-time equipment purchase, startup costs, etc.) and wait until you have 2 consecutive profitable years before applying.

Can bonus income alone qualify me for a HELOC without base salary?

Unlikely. Lenders view bonuses as supplemental and discretionary. They want to see base salary or other stable income as the primary source. If 80%+ of your income is bonuses, some lenders will treat you like a commission-based employee (requiring 2-year history and averaging) while others may not count the bonus income at all.

Related Articles

• [[Home [Equity Explained](/blog/home-equity-explained)](/blog/what-is-home-equity): What It Is and How to Build It](/blog/home-equity-explained)
• Blended Family Home Planning: Merging Households and Managing Home Equity
• [[Bonus Depreciation](/blog/depreciation-rental-property-guide) for Real Estate in 2026: What's Changed](/blog/bonus-depreciation-real-estate-2026)