Short-Term vs Long-Term Rental DSCR: Which Qualifies Better?

The explosion of Airbnb and VRBO has created a fundamental question for investors seeking DSCR financing: Does short-term rental (STR) income qualify as easily as traditional long-term rental (LTR) income?

The answer is nuanced: Long-term rentals qualify more easily, but short-term rentals can achieve higher DSCR ratios when properly documented. Understanding the differences in underwriting, documentation, and lender appetite is critical for choosing the right strategy.

The Core Difference in Income Verification

Long-Term Rental Income (LTR)

What it is: Traditional 12-month leases to residential tenants Documentation: Simple and standardized

• Executed lease agreement showing monthly rent
• Security deposit receipt
• Market rent analysis (if property isn't yet rented)

DSCR calculation: Monthly DSCR = Monthly Lease Rent ÷ (P&I + Taxes + Insurance + HOA)

Example:

• Lease rent: $2,000/month
• PITIA: $1,600/month
• DSCR: $2,000 ÷ $1,600 = 1.25

Lender comfort: Very high. Long-term leases provide predictable, contracted income.

Short-Term Rental Income (STR)

What it is: Nightly rentals via Airbnb, VRBO, etc. Documentation: Complex and variable

• 12-24 months of booking platform reports (Airbnb/VRBO statements)
• Tax returns (Schedule E showing rental income)
• Market comparable analysis (AirDNA, Mashvisor)

DSCR calculation: Monthly DSCR = (Average Monthly STR Income × Occupancy Rate) ÷ (PITIA + Operating Expenses)

Example:

• Average nightly rate: $200
• Average monthly bookings: 18 nights (60% occupancy)
• Gross monthly income: $200 × 18 = $3,600
• Operating expenses: $900 (utilities, cleaning, supplies, platform fees)
• Net income: $2,700
• PITIA: $1,800
• DSCR: $2,700 ÷ $1,800 = 1.50

Lender comfort: Lower. STR income is variable, seasonal, and dependent on active management.

Why Long-Term Rentals Qualify More Easily

1. Standardized Documentation

Every LTR loan looks the same:

• Signed lease
• Market rent comp (Zillow, Rentometer)
• Appraisal supporting rental value

Underwriters can approve in minutes.

STR loans require:

• Platform income statements
• Tax return reconciliation
• Seasonal adjustment analysis
• Expense documentation
• Market feasibility studies

Underwriters need hours to review.

2. More DSCR Lenders Accept LTR

LTR acceptance: 95%+ of DSCR lenders STR acceptance: 40-60% of DSCR lenders

Many lenders simply don't have STR underwriting guidelines in place.

3. Lower Perceived Risk

LTR risks (lender view):

• Tenant default (mitigated by security deposits, eviction process)
• Property damage (insurable, manageable)
• Vacancy (predictable, local market data available)

STR risks (lender view):

• Regulatory changes (cities banning STRs)
• Platform policy changes (Airbnb changing search algorithms)
• Seasonal volatility (summer boom, winter bust)
• Management intensity (requires active operation)
• Competitive market shifts (new hotels, other STRs)

Lenders price risk into rates and approve LTRs more readily.

4. Easier Appraisals

LTR appraisals:

• Standard residential appraisal
• Rent comparable analysis (simple)
• Every appraiser knows how to do it

STR appraisals:

• May require commercial appraisal
• Income approach using STR comps (appraiser must research)
• Cap rate analysis
• Not all appraisers are familiar with STR valuation

5. Simpler Exit Strategy

If an LTR investor defaults:

• Lender forecloses
• Property sells to another investor or homeowner
• Easy to re-lease as LTR

If an STR investor defaults:

• Property may not work as LTR (location, layout)
• STR regulations may have changed
• Requires finding another STR operator or converting use

Lenders prefer simple liquidation paths.

When Short-Term Rentals Qualify Better

Despite the challenges, STRs can achieve superior DSCR ratios when income is substantially higher than LTR alternatives.

Scenario 1: High-Demand Tourist Markets

Property: 2-bedroom condo near beach

• LTR market rent: $1,800/month
• STR average: $180/night × 22 nights = $3,960/month
• STR after expenses (30%): $2,772/month

DSCR comparison:

• LTR DSCR: $1,800 ÷ $1,500 = 1.20 (barely qualifies)
• STR DSCR: $2,772 ÷ $1,500 = 1.85 (strong qualification)

When this works: Beachfront, ski resorts, major cities with strong tourism

Scenario 2: Unique Properties

Property: Mountain cabin with hot tub, mountain views

• LTR demand: Minimal (remote location)
• LTR market rent: $1,200/month
• STR potential: $250/night × 15 nights = $3,750/month

DSCR comparison:

• LTR DSCR: $1,200 ÷ $1,600 = 0.75 (doesn't qualify)
• STR DSCR: $2,625 ÷ $1,600 = 1.64 (qualifies well)

When this works: Unique locations where vacation demand exceeds residential demand

Scenario 3: Established STR with History

Property: Existing Airbnb with 2 years of performance data

• Documented income: $4,200/month average
• Consistent occupancy: 65-70% year-round
• Strong reviews: 4.9 stars, Superhost status

DSCR calculation:

• Proven income: $4,200
• Expenses (documented): $1,100
• Net: $3,100
• PITIA: $2,000
• DSCR: $3,100 ÷ $2,000 = 1.55

When this works: Buying turnkey STR with proven track record

Scenario 4: Multi-Use Properties

Property: 3-bedroom house that works as both LTR and STR

• LTR fallback rent: $2,000/month (DSCR 1.20)
• STR optimized income: $3,500/month (DSCR 2.10)

Lender perspective: Lower risk because property can convert to LTR if STR market declines.

Documentation Requirements Compared

Long-Term Rental Documentation

For existing rentals:

• Current lease agreement
• Security deposit receipt
• 12 months bank statements showing rent deposits
• Tax return Schedule E (if owned >1 year)

For new/vacant properties:

• Market rent analysis (Zillow, Rentometer, CMA)
• Appraisal with rental income opinion
• Comparable rent survey

Timeline to gather: 1-3 days

Short-Term Rental Documentation

For existing STRs:

• 12-24 months Airbnb/VRBO income statements
• Tax returns (Schedule E) showing STR income
• Expense documentation (cleaning, utilities, supplies, platform fees)
• Occupancy rate analysis by season
• Booking platform performance dashboard
• Business license (if required locally)

For new/proposed STRs:

• Market analysis (AirDNA, Mashvisor projections)
• Comparable STR performance data
• Management plan (self-managed vs. property manager)
• Local regulation compliance verification
• Projected income and expense pro forma

Timeline to gather: 1-2 weeks

How Lenders Calculate DSCR for Each Model

Long-Term Rental DSCR Formula

Simple version: DSCR = Monthly Rent ÷ (P&I + T + I + HOA)

Conservative lender version: DSCR = (Monthly Rent × 0.75) ÷ (P&I + T + I + HOA)

Some lenders haircut rent by 25% to account for vacancy and management.

Example:

• Rent: $2,000
• Haircut rent: $1,500
• PITIA: $1,600
• DSCR: $1,500 ÷ $1,600 = 0.94 (doesn't qualify)

Solution: Increase rent, reduce loan amount, or find lender without haircut.

Short-Term Rental DSCR Formula

Gross income approach: DSCR = (Average Monthly Gross Income × Occupancy %) ÷ (PITIA + Operating Expenses)

Net income approach: DSCR = Net Monthly Income (after all expenses) ÷ PITIA

Most lenders use net income approach and apply additional haircuts:

Example calculation:

• Average daily rate: $200
• Average monthly nights booked: 20 (historical)
• Gross monthly: $4,000
• Operating expenses: 35% ($1,400)
• Net income: $2,600
• Lender haircut: 20% (for seasonality/variability)
• Adjusted income: $2,080
• PITIA: $1,800
• DSCR: $2,080 ÷ $1,800 = 1.16 (doesn't quite qualify)

This is why STR DSCR loans are harder—lenders apply multiple conservative adjustments.

Operating Expense Assumptions

LTR operating expenses: Usually excluded from DSCR or minimal

• Lenders assume tenant pays utilities
• Tenant handles minor maintenance
• Minimal landlord operating costs

STR operating expenses: Substantial and deducted from income

• Platform fees (15-20%)
• Cleaning fees (10-15% per stay)
• Utilities (5-8%)
• Supplies and amenities (3-5%)
• Property management (if used): 20-30%
• Total: 30-50% of gross income

This dramatically reduces net income for DSCR calculation.

Lender Requirements and Restrictions

Long-Term Rental Lender Requirements

Typical minimums:

• Credit score: 660-680
• Down payment: 20-25%
• Reserves: 6-12 months PITIA
• DSCR: 1.20-1.25
• Property type: Standard residential
• Experience: None required (most lenders)

Widely available: 50+ lenders offering LTR DSCR loans

Short-Term Rental Lender Requirements

Typical minimums:

• Credit score: 680-720 (higher than LTR)
• Down payment: 25-30% (higher than LTR)
• Reserves: 12-18 months PITIA (higher than LTR)
• DSCR: 1.25-1.30 (higher than LTR)
• Property type: Must be STR-appropriate
• Experience: 1-2+ years STR management preferred
• Seasoning: 12-24 months operating history preferred

Limited availability: 20-30 lenders offering STR DSCR loans

Additional STR Lender Restrictions

1. Location restrictions Lenders often limit STR loans to:

• Proven tourist markets (beach, ski, major cities)
• Areas with favorable STR regulations
• Properties within X miles of tourist attractions

2. Regulatory compliance Lenders require:

• Proof of legal STR operation (business license, permits)
• Verification that STRs are allowed by local zoning
• Insurance covering short-term rental activity

3. Income documentation standards Many lenders require:

• Minimum 12 months operating history
• Tax return showing STR income (Schedule E)
• Third-party income verification (Airbnb statements)

4. Property condition STRs must be:

• Fully furnished and operational
• In excellent condition (higher than LTR standard)
• Professionally photographed and marketed

Rate and Fee Comparison

Long-Term Rental DSCR Rates

• Interest rates: 7.0% - 8.5% (typical market range)
• Points: 0-2 points
• Closing costs: Standard (2-3% of loan amount)

Short-Term Rental DSCR Rates

• Interest rates: 7.5% - 9.5% (0.5%-1% higher than LTR)
• Points: 1-3 points (higher than LTR)
• Closing costs: 3-4% of loan amount

Rate premium explanation: Lenders charge more for perceived higher risk, volatility, and regulatory uncertainty.

Example:

• LTR loan: $300,000 at 7.5% = $2,098/month
• STR loan: $300,000 at 8.5% = $2,307/month
• Monthly cost difference: $209

Is the premium worth it? Only if STR income exceeds LTR income by enough to cover the higher payment and still deliver better cash flow.

Hybrid Strategy: Mid-Term Rentals (MTR)

Some investors use mid-term rentals (30-90 day stays) as a middle ground.

How it works:

• Rent to traveling nurses, corporate relocations, students
• 1-6 month lease terms
• Furnished units
• Higher than LTR rent, lower than STR variability

DSCR qualification:

• Some lenders treat as LTR (if 30+ day stays)
• Others treat as STR (if furnished, short-term)

Advantages:

• Higher income than LTR
• More stable than STR
• Fewer local regulatory issues (30+ day stays often exempt)
• Less operational intensity than nightly STR

Example:

• LTR rent: $1,800/month
• MTR rent: $2,500/month (furnished, utilities included)
• STR potential: $3,200/month (but higher variability)

Best for: Investors wanting premium income without full STR management burden.

Decision Framework: Which Model Is Right for You?

Choose Long-Term Rentals If:

• You want simple, passive income
• You're financing properties in suburban/non-tourist areas
• You have limited real estate experience
• You prefer stable, predictable cash flow
• You want the widest lender selection
• You're building a large portfolio (ease of scaling)
• Local STR regulations are unfavorable

Choose Short-Term Rentals If:

• Property is in a proven tourist market
• STR income is 40%+ higher than LTR
• You have STR management experience
• You're willing to actively operate the property
• You can provide 12+ months STR income history
• Local regulations allow STR operation
• You can afford higher down payments and rates
• You're comfortable with income variability

Choose Mid-Term Rentals If:

• You want higher income than LTR with less work than STR
• Property appeals to corporate/medical travelers
• Local STR regulations are restrictive
• You want furnished rental premium without nightly turnover
• You qualify more easily (some lenders treat as LTR)

Converting Between Models Post-Acquisition

LTR to STR Conversion

Process:

• Purchase with LTR DSCR loan
• Operate as LTR initially
• After 12-24 months, convert to STR
• Refinance to STR DSCR loan (if better terms available)

Pros:

• Easier initial financing
• Prove STR concept before committing

Cons:

• May violate loan terms (check for property use restrictions)
• Requires refinancing (costs 2-3% of loan amount)

STR to LTR Conversion

Process:

• If STR underperforms or regulations change
• Convert to traditional long-term rental
• May not need to refinance (check loan terms)

Pros:

• Flexibility to adapt to market changes
• Most STR properties can function as LTR

Cons:

• Income typically drops
• May violate DSCR covenant if income falls too low

Key: Review your loan documents for "property use" clauses restricting rental type changes.

Real-World Comparison

Property: 3-bedroom house in Orlando, FL (near Disney) Purchase price: $350,000 Loan: $280,000 (80% LTV) at 7.75% Monthly P&I: $2,017 Taxes + Insurance: $450 Total PITIA: $2,467

Scenario A: Long-Term Rental

Income:

• Market rent: $2,200/month
• Vacancy (5%): -$110
• Net income: $2,090

DSCR: $2,090 ÷ $2,467 = 0.85 ❌ (Doesn't qualify)

Solution: Reduce loan to $240,000 (68% LTV)

• New PITIA: $2,142
• DSCR: $2,090 ÷ $2,142 = 0.98 (still doesn't qualify)
• Need down payment of $110,000+ to make LTR work

Scenario B: Short-Term Rental

Income:

• Average nightly rate: $180
• Average nights booked: 20/month (67% occupancy)
• Gross income: $3,600/month
• Operating expenses (40%): -$1,440
• Net income: $2,160

DSCR: $2,160 ÷ $2,467 = 0.88 ❌ (Doesn't qualify)

But lender requires 25% down for STR:

• New loan: $262,500
• New PITIA: $2,348
• DSCR: $2,160 ÷ $2,348 = 0.92 (still short)

Increase occupancy to 24 nights (80%):

• Gross income: $4,320
• Net after expenses: $2,592
• DSCR: $2,592 ÷ $2,348 = 1.10 (still marginal)

This property works marginally for STR, not at all for LTR.

Investor decision: Either find higher-cash-flow property or increase down payment to 30%+ for both strategies.

FAQ

Can I switch from LTR to STR after closing my DSCR loan? Check your loan documents. Some loans restrict property use changes. Violating this can trigger due-on-sale clauses. Always consult your lender before changing rental models.

Do lenders care if I self-manage STR vs. use a property manager? Some do. Lenders may prefer professional management (reduces operational risk) or require it for inexperienced investors. Self-management can work if you have proven track record.

Can I use projected STR income for a property I haven't operated yet? Some lenders allow this with robust market analysis (AirDNA, comparable STR data). Most prefer 12+ months actual operating history. Expect higher down payments (30%) for projections.

What if my STR has great summer income but slow winters? Lenders annualize income, so seasonal properties can work if annual average DSCR meets minimums. However, you need reserves to cover slow months, and some lenders apply haircuts to seasonal properties.

Is a DSCR loan for STR different from a traditional vacation home loan? Yes. Vacation home loans assume personal use (not rental income). DSCR STR loans are investment properties where you qualify based on rental income, not personal income.

Can I combine LTR and STR income (rent 9 months LTR, 3 months STR)? Creative, but most lenders won't underwrite hybrid models. Choose one strategy for qualification purposes.

Which rental model has better tax advantages? Both offer depreciation, expense deductions, and 1031 exchange eligibility. STRs may qualify for additional deductions (furnishings, supplies) and potentially active income treatment (avoiding passive loss limitations) if you materially participate.

Do I need different insurance for STR vs LTR? Yes. STR requires specialized short-term rental insurance or commercial landlord policies. Standard landlord insurance may not cover nightly rentals. Lenders often require proof of appropriate STR coverage.

Can I get a DSCR loan for a property that's part-time LTR, part-time personal use? No. DSCR loans are for investment properties only. Personal use disqualifies the property from DSCR financing (triggers vacation home or second home loan requirements).

What happens if STR regulations change after I close? You're generally still obligated to repay the loan. You may need to convert to LTR or sell. This is why lenders carefully evaluate regulatory risk before approving STR loans.

---

Bottom Line: Long-term rentals qualify more easily for DSCR loans due to simpler documentation, wider lender availability, and lower perceived risk. Short-term rentals can achieve superior DSCR ratios when income substantially exceeds LTR alternatives, but require more documentation, higher down payments, experienced management, and favorable local regulations. Choose your strategy based on property location, local market dynamics, your management capacity, and financing availability—not assumptions about which model is universally "better."

Related Articles

• 1031 Exchange for Beginners: Complete Guide to Deferring Capital Gains Taxes
• 1031 Exchange: Defer Taxes, Build Wealth Faster
• Credit Score Requirements for DSCR Loans