[DSCR](/blog/what-is-dscr-ratio) Loan Exit Strategies: Sell, Refi, or Hold?

Buying a property with a DSCR loan is just the beginning. The real money is made—or lost—in the exit. Whether you sell for capital gains, refinance to extract equity, or hold for long-term cash flow, each path has different tax implications, timing considerations, and financial outcomes.

Most investors don't plan their exit until they're forced to make a decision. That's backwards. Your exit strategy should inform your purchase decision, financing structure, and holding period from day one.

This guide breaks down the three primary exit strategies for DSCR-financed properties, when each makes sense, and how to execute them for maximum returns while avoiding costly mistakes.

The Three Exit Paths

1. Sell (Disposition)

Exchange the property for cash, realizing capital gains (or losses) and exiting the investment entirely.

When it makes sense:

• Property has appreciated significantly
• You need liquidity for other investments or personal needs
• Property has become management-intensive or problematic
• Market conditions favor sellers (low inventory, high demand)
• You're ready to exit real estate or rebalance your portfolio

Tax implications:

• Capital gains tax on appreciation (federal 15-20% + 3.8% NIIT + state taxes)
• [Depreciation recapture](/blog/depreciation-real-estate-guide) at 25%
• Can defer with [1031 exchange](/blog/1031-exchange-guide)

2. Refinance (Extract Equity)

Replace the existing DSCR loan with a new loan, often at a higher amount, pulling out accumulated equity while retaining ownership.

When it makes sense:

• Property has appreciated and/or you've paid down the loan
• Interest rates have dropped since your original loan
• You want to access equity without selling (and triggering taxes)
• Cash flow can support the new, larger payment
• You believe the property will continue appreciating

Tax implications:

• No immediate taxes (refinances aren't taxable events)
• Can access equity tax-free
• Depreciation continues

3. Hold (Long-Term Ownership)

Keep the property, continue collecting rent, pay down the mortgage, and defer any decision until market conditions or personal circumstances change.

When it makes sense:

• Cash flow is strong and covering expenses comfortably
• You believe appreciation will continue
• You're building long-term wealth and don't need liquidity
• Tax deferral is a priority (avoiding capital gains and recapture)
• You're waiting for more favorable market conditions to sell or refinance

Tax implications:

• Ongoing income taxes on rental profit (offset by depreciation)
• No capital gains until sale
• Estate planning benefit (heirs receive step-up in basis at your death)

Exit Strategy #1: Selling the Property

When to Sell

Market timing indicators:

• High appreciation: Property value has increased 30-50%+ since purchase
• Low inventory: Buyer demand exceeds supply, driving prices up
• Rising cap rates: If cap rates in your market are compressing (falling), values are rising—potentially a good time to sell before they expand again
• Peak of cycle: Real estate markets are cyclical; selling near the peak captures maximum gains

Property-specific indicators:

• Declining neighborhood: Crime increasing, schools deteriorating, major employers leaving
• Deferred maintenance accumulating: Roof, HVAC, foundation issues would require major capital investment
• Tenant problems: Chronic vacancy, [difficult tenants](/blog/dealing-with-problem-tenants), rising management costs
• Better opportunities elsewhere: You've identified higher-return investments

Personal indicators:

• Liquidity needs: Down payment for a larger property, business investment, or personal expenses
• Portfolio rebalancing: Too concentrated in one market or property type
• Retirement: Transitioning from active real estate to passive income (stocks, bonds, REITs)

Selling Process with a DSCR Loan

Step 1: Check your loan for prepayment penalties

Many [DSCR loans](/blog/dscr-loan-guide) include prepayment penalties, especially:

• Loans with rate discounts or rebates
• Commercial loans (defeasance, yield maintenance, or step-down penalties common)
• CMBS loans (often have strict prepayment restrictions)

Types of prepayment penalties:

Fixed percentage: E.g., 3% of loan balance if sold in Year 1, 2% in Year 2, 1% in Year 3, 0% thereafter

Yield maintenance: Complex calculation ensuring the lender earns the same yield as if you held the loan to maturity (can be expensive in falling-rate environments)

Defeasance: You must purchase Treasury securities that replicate the loan's cash flows (common in CMBS loans, very expensive)

Step-down (graduated): Penalty decreases over time (e.g., 5-4-3-2-1% over five years)

Check your loan documents or call your lender. Prepayment penalties can easily cost $10,000-$100,000+ on larger loans.

Step 2: Price the property

Work with an agent or appraiser to determine market value. Compare:

• Recent comps (similar properties sold in the last 3-6 months)
• Cap rate (your NOI ÷ expected sale price should align with market cap rates)
• Price per unit (for multifamily)
• Price per square foot

Pricing strategy:

• Aggressive: Price 5-10% above comps to test the market
• Market: Price at comps for a quick sale
• Conservative: Price slightly below comps if you need certainty and speed

Step 3: Market and sell

List with an experienced agent (residential or commercial, depending on property type). Expect:

• 30-90 days on market (varies by location and property type)
• Inspections, appraisal, and buyer due diligence (15-30 days)
• Closing (30-45 days from accepted offer)

Total timeline: 2-4 months from listing to closing.

Step 4: Pay off the DSCR loan and closing costs

At closing:

• DSCR loan is paid off (including any [prepayment penalty](/blog/dscr-loan-prepayment-penalty))
• Closing costs (agent commission, title, escrow, transfer taxes) are deducted
• Net proceeds go to you

Typical closing costs: 7-10% of sale price (6% agent commission + 1-4% other costs).

Example:

• Sale price: $600,000
• Loan payoff: $420,000
• Prepayment penalty: $8,400 (2%)
• Closing costs: $48,000 (8%)
• Net proceeds: $123,600

Step 5: Pay taxes (or defer with 1031 exchange)

Capital gains and depreciation recapture are due the following tax year unless you execute a 1031 exchange.

Tax calculation (non-1031 sale):

• Original purchase: $500,000
• Depreciation claimed: $60,000
• Adjusted basis: $440,000
• Sale price: $600,000
• Capital gain: $160,000
• Capital gains tax (20% + 3.8% NIIT + 5% state): $46,080
• Depreciation recapture (25%): $15,000
• Total taxes: $61,080

After-tax net proceeds: $123,600 - $61,080 = $62,520

1031 Exchange to Defer Taxes

If you don't need the cash, a 1031 exchange defers all capital gains and depreciation recapture by reinvesting proceeds into a replacement property.

Requirements:

• Identify replacement property within 45 days
• Close on replacement within 180 days
• Replacement must be equal or greater value
• Must replace or exceed debt to avoid taxable boot

Benefit: $61,080 in taxes deferred, allowing you to reinvest the full $123,600 into a larger property.

(See our detailed article on DSCR Loans and 1031 Exchanges for complete strategy.)

Exit Strategy #2: Refinancing

[When to Refinance](/blog/mortgage-refinance-guide)

Rate improvement:

• Interest rates have dropped 0.75%+ since your original DSCR loan
• Your credit score has improved significantly
• You've built strong payment history, qualifying for better terms

Equity accumulation:

• Property has appreciated 20%+ since purchase
• You've paid down the loan significantly
• You want to access equity without selling

[Cash-out refinance](/blog/cash-out-refinance-guide):

• Extract equity for another down payment, renovations, or other investments
• Typical max LTV on cash-out DSCR refi: 70-75%

Term optimization:

• Original loan was a 5-year balloon; you want long-term fixed financing
• Original loan was high-rate hard money; transitioning to permanent DSCR financing

Refinance Process

Step 1: Check prepayment penalties

Same as selling—many DSCR loans penalize early payoff. Calculate whether the savings from a lower rate (or the benefit of cash-out equity) exceed the penalty.

Example:

• Current loan: $400,000 @ 7.5%, prepayment penalty: 2% ($8,000)
• Refinance: $400,000 @ 6.0%
• Monthly savings: $293 ($2,808 vs $3,101)
• Annual savings: $3,516
• Payback period: 2.3 years ($8,000 ÷ $3,516)

If you plan to hold 3+ years, the refi makes sense despite the penalty.

Step 2: Get the property appraised

Lenders require a new appraisal to determine current value and equity.

Example:

• Original purchase: $500,000
• Current loan balance: $380,000
• New appraisal: $620,000
• Equity: $240,000
• LTV: 61%

Cash-out potential (75% LTV max):

• New loan amount: $620,000 × 0.75 = $465,000
• Payoff existing loan: $380,000
• Cash-out: $85,000 (minus closing costs)

Step 3: Apply for the new DSCR loan

Process is similar to the original purchase:

• Provide property financials (rent roll, lease agreements)
• Appraisal ordered
• DSCR calculated based on new loan payment
• Credit check and underwriting

Timeline: 10-30 days depending on lender.

Step 4: Close and pay off old loan

New lender funds the refinance, pays off the old loan (including any prepayment penalty), and issues the cash-out check (if applicable).

Closing costs: Typically 2-5% of loan amount (appraisal, title, lender fees, escrow).

Rate-and-Term Refi vs Cash-Out Refi

Rate-and-term refinance:

• Replace existing loan with similar balance at better rate/terms
• No cash out
• Lower closing costs
• Higher max LTV (often 80%)

Cash-out refinance:

• Increase loan balance to extract equity
• Receive cash at closing
• Higher rates (lenders price cash-out refis 0.25-0.50% higher)
• Lower max LTV (typically 70-75%)

Tax note: Refinances are not taxable events. You can pull out $100,000 in equity tax-free (though the interest on the cash-out portion may or may not be deductible depending on how you use the funds—consult your CPA).

Exit Strategy #3: Hold Long-Term

Why Hold?

Cash flow compounding:

• Each year, rents increase (inflation + market demand)
• Fixed mortgage payment stays the same
• Cash flow gap widens annually

Example:

• Year 1 rent: $3,000/month, mortgage: $2,400, cash flow: $600/month ($7,200/year)
• Year 10 rent (3% annual increase): $3,930/month, mortgage: $2,400, cash flow: $1,530/month ($18,360/year)

Cash flow more than doubled while the mortgage stayed flat.

Loan paydown:

• Each payment reduces principal
• After 10 years on a 30-year loan, you've paid down ~15-20% of the original balance
• At year 30, the loan is paid off entirely, and cash flow skyrockets

Tax deferral:

• No capital gains or recapture until you sell
• Depreciation continues to shelter income
• At death, heirs receive step-up in basis, erasing all deferred gains

Appreciation:

• Real estate historically appreciates 3-5% annually
• Leverage amplifies returns (e.g., 4% appreciation on a property with 75% LTV = 16% return on equity)

When to Hold

Strong fundamentals:

• Property is in a growing market (population growth, job growth, new development)
• Cash flow is stable and covering expenses with room to spare
• Property is well-maintained with no major capital expenses looming

Favorable tax position:

• You're in a high tax bracket and want to defer gains
• You're building generational wealth and plan to pass properties to heirs
• You're using depreciation to offset other income (real estate professional status)

No better use for capital:

• Alternative investments don't offer better risk-adjusted returns
• You lack liquidity needs
• You're happy with passive income and don't want the hassle of deploying capital elsewhere

Managing Long-Term Holds

Annual reviews:

• Reassess property value (check comps)
• Review rent vs market (are you under-market?)
• Inspect property condition (preventative maintenance cheaper than reactive)
• Evaluate cash flow (are expenses creeping up?)

Refinance opportunistically:

• If rates drop significantly, refinance to lower payments or pull equity
• If property appreciates substantially, access equity for other investments

Capital improvements:

• Invest in value-add improvements (kitchen/bath updates, energy efficiency) to maintain competitiveness and justify rent increases
• Budget for major replacements (roof, HVAC, etc.) to avoid cash flow shocks

Tax optimization:

• Track depreciation and consider cost segregation for accelerated deductions
• Plan eventual exit (1031 exchange vs outright sale vs hold until death)

Comparing the Three Strategies: Financial Modeling

Property: Purchased for $500,000 with $400,000 DSCR loan at 7%, 30-year amortization. Current value: $650,000. Current loan balance: $380,000. NOI: $45,000/year.

Option 1: Sell Now

• Sale price: $650,000
• Loan payoff: $380,000
• Closing costs (8%): $52,000
• Net proceeds: $218,000
• Capital gains + recapture taxes (30% effective): $65,400
• After-tax proceeds: $152,600

Pros: Liquidity, capture gains, redeploy capital Cons: Taxes, lose future cash flow and appreciation

Option 2: Cash-Out Refinance

• New appraisal: $650,000

• New loan (75% LTV): $487,500

• Payoff old loan: $380,000

• Cash-out: $107,500

• Closing costs (3%): $14,625

• Net cash: $92,875 (tax-free)

• New payment: $3,242/month (vs $2,661 old)

• DSCR on new loan: $45,000 ÷ $38,904 = 1.16 (acceptable)

• Cash flow drops from $800/month to $510/month but you have $92,875 to deploy elsewhere

Pros: Access equity tax-free, retain property and future appreciation Cons: Higher payment, reduced cash flow, more debt

Option 3: Hold

• Keep existing loan ($380,000 balance, $2,661/month payment)
• Current cash flow: ~$800/month ($9,600/year)
• Projected appreciation (3%/year): $650,000 → $871,000 in 10 years
• Loan balance in 10 years: $290,000
• Equity in 10 years: $581,000
• Cumulative cash flow (10 years, assuming 2% rent growth): ~$115,000

Total wealth in 10 years: $696,000 (equity + cumulative cash flow)

Pros: Maximum long-term wealth, tax deferral, compounding cash flow Cons: Capital tied up, no liquidity, opportunity cost if better investments exist

Which Strategy Wins?

It depends on your goals:

If you need liquidity now: Sell (Option 1) If you want equity access but believe in the property: Refinance (Option 2) If you're building long-term wealth and don't need cash: Hold (Option 3)

Risk-adjusted, Option 3 (hold) typically generates the most wealth if the property is in a stable or growing market and cash flow is solid. The power of leverage, tax deferral, and compounding is hard to beat.

Common Exit Mistakes

Selling Too Early

Many investors sell after 2-3 years to "take profits," triggering capital gains taxes and losing out on years of compounding cash flow and appreciation.

Better approach: Hold for 7-10+ years unless fundamentals change or you have a compelling reason to exit.

Ignoring Prepayment Penalties

Selling or refinancing without checking prepayment penalties can cost tens of thousands unexpectedly.

Solution: Review your loan documents before making any exit decision. Factor penalties into your financial analysis.

Over-Leveraging on Refinance

Pulling out maximum equity feels great until the market turns and cash flow tightens.

Risk: If rents drop or vacancy increases, an over-leveraged property can turn cash-flow negative quickly.

Solution: Refinance conservatively. Leave a cushion (aim for 1.25+ DSCR after refinance, not 1.10).

Failing to Plan for Taxes

Selling without a 1031 exchange plan or underestimating capital gains taxes reduces net proceeds significantly.

Solution: Consult a CPA before selling. Model after-tax proceeds to understand the real return.

Emotional Decision-Making

Selling because you're "tired of being a landlord" or because a neighbor sold for a high price are emotional decisions, not strategic ones.

Solution: Make exit decisions based on financial analysis, market conditions, and long-term goals—not emotions or external pressure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I sell or refinance if I need cash?

Refinancing avoids capital gains taxes, making it the better option if you need liquidity but believe the property will continue appreciating. Selling makes sense if you no longer want the property or need more cash than a refinance can provide.

Can I refinance a DSCR loan into a conventional loan?

Yes, if you now have W-2 income and can qualify based on personal income. Conventional loans often have lower rates than DSCR loans. However, you'll need full income documentation, which DSCR loans don't require.

How long should I hold a DSCR-financed property?

Minimum 5 years to allow appreciation and cash flow to compound. Ideally 10+ years for maximum wealth building. Only sell earlier if fundamentals deteriorate or exceptional opportunities arise.

Do I have to pay taxes when I refinance?

No. Refinances are not taxable events, even if you pull out cash. However, the interest on cash-out funds may not be fully deductible depending on how you use the money (consult your CPA).

What if my property hasn't appreciated—should I still hold?

Depends on cash flow. If the property generates positive cash flow and you're paying down debt, holding can still make sense even with flat appreciation. If it's cash-flow negative or problematic, selling or finding a turnaround strategy may be better.

Can I do a 1031 exchange and then refinance the replacement property?

Yes. After completing a 1031 exchange, you can refinance the replacement property anytime (though some advisors recommend waiting 6-12 months to avoid IRS scrutiny around cash-extraction motives).

How do I decide between selling and holding if the market is peaking?

Market timing is difficult. If you're confident the market is at a cyclical peak and you've captured significant gains, selling (or 1031 exchanging) makes sense. If you're uncertain, holding and reassessing annually is safer.

What's the best exit strategy for building generational wealth?

Hold long-term and pass properties to heirs, who receive a step-up in basis (erasing all deferred capital gains). This allows decades of tax-deferred growth with no eventual tax liability for your heirs.

---

Your exit strategy is as important as your acquisition strategy. The most successful DSCR loan investors plan their exit from day one, understanding the tax implications, timing considerations, and financial trade-offs of selling, refinancing, or holding.

For most investors, holding long-term generates the greatest wealth through compounding cash flow, appreciation, and tax deferral. Refinancing provides liquidity when needed without triggering taxes. Selling should be reserved for situations where fundamentals have changed, you have better opportunities, or you're at a life stage where liquidity matters more than long-term growth.

Evaluate your options annually, stay flexible, and make exit decisions based on data and goals—not emotions or market noise. The right exit, executed at the right time, can be the difference between modest returns and life-changing wealth.

Related Articles

• 1031 Exchange for Beginners: Complete Guide to Deferring Capital Gains Taxes
• 1031 Exchange: Defer Taxes, Build Wealth Faster
• Credit Score Requirements for DSCR Loans